Who is Better Quarterback: Tom Brady or Patrick Mahomes

By Jason Bolton February 13, 2024 03:12

Photo by AP Photo/Steven Senne

When it comes to comparing quarterbacks in the NFL, two names that often enter the conversation are Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes. Both players have achieved remarkable success in their careers, but the debate about who is the better quarterback continues to divide fans and experts alike.

Tom Brady

Career Achievements

Super Bowl Success: Tom Brady has won seven Super Bowl titles, more than any other player in NFL history.
MVP Awards: He has been named the Super Bowl MVP five times and has also received three NFL MVP awards.
Consistency: Throughout his career, Brady has displayed remarkable consistency in his performance, leading his teams to numerous playoff appearances.

Playing Style and Skills

Experience: With over two decades of experience in the NFL, Brady's knowledge of the game and ability to read defenses is unparalleled.
Accuracy: He is known for his precise passing and ability to deliver the ball with pinpoint accuracy.
Leadership: Brady's leadership on and off the field is widely respected, and he has a proven track record of elevating the performance of his teammates.

Patrick Mahomes

Career Achievements

Super Bowl Victories: Mahomes led the Kansas City Chiefs to a Super Bowl win in 3 years and was named the game's MVP in all games.
NFL MVP: In 2018 and 2022, Mahomes was named the NFL MVP after a remarkable season in which he threw for over 5,000 yards and 50 touchdowns.
Early Success: Despite being relatively early in his career, Mahomes has already achieved significant milestones and has been widely recognized for his exceptional talent.

Playing Style and Skills

Athleticism: Mahomes is known for his remarkable athleticism, often making plays with his feet as well as his arm.
Arm Talent: He possesses one of the strongest arms in the NFL and is capable of making throws that few other quarterbacks can.
Creativity: Mahomes is known for his ability to improvise and make plays outside of the designed structure of the offense, often turning broken plays into big gains.

Statistical Comparison

When comparing the statistical accomplishments of both quarterbacks, it is evident that both Brady and Mahomes have impressive numbers in various categories. Brady holds several NFL records for passing yards, touchdowns, and completions, while Mahomes has quickly established himself as one of the most prolific passers in the league.

Team Support and Surrounding Talent

The success of a quarterback is often attributed to the support and talent surrounding them. Brady enjoyed a long and successful tenure with the New England Patriots, benefiting from the coaching of Bill Belichick and a strong supporting cast. In contrast, Mahomes has thrived under the guidance of Andy Reid and has been surrounded by dynamic playmakers on the Chiefs' offense.

Impact on the Game

Both Brady and Mahomes have had a significant impact on the game of football. Brady's success and longevity have solidified his place as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, while Mahomes' electrifying playing style and early accomplishments have drawn widespread acclaim and have the potential to reshape the quarterback position.

The debate about who is the better quarterback between Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes is a complex and subjective one. While Brady's sustained success and numerous accolades speak to his greatness, Mahomes' remarkable talent and early achievements hint at a future filled with potential. Ultimately, the answer to this question may depend on individual perspectives and what criteria are valued most in assessing quarterback excellence.