Is bare-knuckle safer than UFC?
Is bare-knuckle safer than UFC?
By Ali Hammad December 09, 2023 06:16
Combat sports have always fueled debates surrounding their safety and excitement. One particular point of contention is the comparison between bare-knuckle fighting and the Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC). While both sports involve intense physical contact, there are arguments suggesting that bare-knuckle fighting may actually be safer than UFC. This article delves into the contrasting perspectives and factors that contribute to the safety of these combat sports.
The Argument for Bare-Knuckle Boxing
Proponents of bare-knuckle boxing argue that it is safer than gloved boxing, citing the lack of fatalities during the bare-knuckle era compared to the current rate of deaths and brain damage in gloved boxing. However, a comprehensive study reveals that there were actually 259 recorded ring deaths before gloves became mandatory, disproving the notion of no fatalities during the bare-knuckle era. It is important to note that this study also identifies a spike in boxing deaths after the implementation of the Marquess of Queensberry Rules, which mandated the use of gloves. This raises questions about the efficacy of gloves in preventing fatalities and brain damage in combat sports.
Fewer Head Injuries in Bare-Knuckle Fighting
Another argument in favor of bare-knuckle fighting's safety is the claim that fighters rarely headhunt, resulting in fewer knockouts and head injuries. Unlike UFC, bare-knuckle fighters are more cautious about breaking their hands, as without gloves, the risk of hand injury is higher. This leads to a more strategic approach, where fighters focus on body shots and overall technique, potentially reducing the occurrence of severe head injuries.
Factors Influencing Safety
Several factors contribute to the safety of combat sports, including the rules and regulations in place, the legitimacy and documentation of the sport, improved data collection methods, and the number of fighters participating.
In the case of bare-knuckle fighting, the rules involve five, two-minute rounds with no kicking, kneeing, or choking allowed. These limitations may minimize the risk of certain types of injuries associated with UFC. However, it is essential to consider that the absence of gloves can result in more cuts and facial damage in bare-knuckle fighting.
Moreover, the increase in deaths and brain damage in gloved boxing after the implementation of the Marquess of Queensberry Rules may be attributed to the sport's growing legitimacy and documentation. With improved data collection methods, incidents that previously went unrecorded are now documented, leading to a higher reported rate of injuries and fatalities.
The UFC, on the other hand, has a comprehensive set of rules and regulations that aim to ensure fighter safety. The sport has weight classes, time limits, and strict medical protocols to protect fighters from unnecessary harm. Additionally, UFC fighters undergo rigorous training and conditioning, which may contribute to their ability to withstand and recover from injuries.
Mixed Responses from the Combat Sports Community
Bare-knuckle fighting has gained popularity in the combat sports community, but it has also received mixed responses. Some argue that the sport's brutal nature puts fighters at significant risk, while others appreciate the raw and authentic style of fighting. The combat sports community remains divided on whether bare-knuckle fighting can ever be considered truly safe.
While the debate surrounding the safety of bare-knuckle fighting and UFC continues, it is important to consider various factors that contribute to the overall safety of these combat sports. Proponents of bare-knuckle boxing argue that the absence of gloves may make it safer, but historical data suggests otherwise. UFC, with its comprehensive rules and regulations, has implemented measures to protect fighters. Ultimately, the safety of these sports depends on a combination of factors, including the rules, fighter training, and the overall approach to injury prevention within each discipline.
LATEST
- NEWS
- |
- ARTICLES
- |
- VIDEOS
FAN ARCH PODCAST NETWORK
