Who is better Drake Maye or JJ McCarthy?

By Jason Bolton April 07, 2024 11:40

Photo by AP Photo/Chuck Burton

In the lead-up to the NFL Draft, the comparison between Drake Maye and JJ McCarthy has been a topic of significant debate and scrutiny.

Both quarterbacks have exhibited remarkable skills and achievements in their collegiate careers, leading to widespread speculation and discussion about their potential in the professional football arena.

Background and Collegiate Performance

Drake Maye

Drake Maye, a standout quarterback from North Carolina, has garnered attention for his exceptional performance on the field. At the age of 21, Maye has showcased impressive physical attributes, standing at 6'4" and weighing 223 pounds.

His collegiate statistics reflect a completion percentage of 63.3, with 24 passing touchdowns and 9 interceptions.

Maye's passing efficiency stands at 149, and he has demonstrated versatility by also contributing 449 rushing yards and 9 rushing touchdowns. However, it is essential to note that his career record as a starting quarterback is 17-9.

JJ McCarthy

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by :) (@jjmccarthy)

On the other hand, JJ McCarthy, hailing from Michigan, has also made a significant impact in the world of collegiate football. At 21 years of age, McCarthy stands at 6'2 1/2" and weighs 219 pounds.

His statistics reveal an impressive completion percentage of 72.3, with 22 passing touchdowns and 4 interceptions. McCarthy's passing efficiency is notably higher at 167.4, and he has displayed agility by amassing 202 rushing yards and 3 rushing touchdowns.

Notably, McCarthy boasts a remarkable career record as a starting quarterback, standing at an impressive 27-1.

Statistical Comparison

When analyzing the statistical performance of both Maye and McCarthy, several key takeaways emerge:

McCarthy's completion percentage surpasses that of Maye by a substantial margin, reflecting a significant advantage in accuracy.
Despite fewer pass attempts, McCarthy has only two fewer passing touchdowns than Maye, emphasizing his efficiency and effectiveness in the passing game.
McCarthy's passing efficiency and Total QBR surpass Maye's, indicating a higher level of proficiency in quarterback performance.
Notably, McCarthy's career record as a starting quarterback significantly outshines Maye's, further accentuating his ability to secure victories against formidable opponents.

Strengths and Weaknesses

Drake Maye

Maye's strengths lie in his physical stature, which provides him with a commanding presence on the field.

His ability to contribute significantly in both passing and rushing aspects of the game demonstrates his versatility and potential to influence various facets of gameplay.

Although, Maye's performance has been marred by a comparatively lower completion percentage and a higher number of interceptions, highlighting areas that may require refinement.

JJ McCarthy

McCarthy's strengths predominantly revolve around his exceptional accuracy, evidenced by his superior completion percentage.

His impressive passing efficiency and remarkable career record as a starting quarterback underscore his ability to lead his team to victories.

Not to mention McCarthy's agility and proficiency in both passing and rushing aspects of the game position him as a multifaceted threat on the field.

Playing Styles and Achievements

Drake Maye

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Drake Maye (@drake.maye)

Maye has demonstrated a playing style characterized by a strong physical presence and the capability to contribute significantly to both passing and rushing aspects of the game.

While his achievements include noteworthy performances in collegiate football, the comparison to McCarthy's career record as a starting quarterback may raise questions about his ability to secure victories against top-tier opponents.

JJ McCarthy

McCarthy's playing style reflects a blend of precision passing, efficient decision-making, and the capacity to influence gameplay through both passing and rushing contributions.

Lastly, The comparison between Drake Maye and JJ McCarthy reveals distinct attributes and performances that warrant careful consideration.

While both individuals have showcased remarkable talent and potential, McCarthy's superior statistical performance, career record as a starting quarterback, and multifaceted playing style position him as a compelling prospect for professional football.

As the NFL Draft approaches, the evaluation of Drake Maye and JJ McCarthy will undoubtedly continue to captivate football enthusiasts and analysts, ultimately culminating in their respective journeys to the professional stage.

The prospect of witnessing their evolution and impact in the realm of professional football adds an element of anticipation and excitement to the forthcoming NFL Draft and the future of the sport.