How Would College Basketball Look if the One-and-Done Rule Disappeared?

How Would College Basketball Look if the One-and-Done Rule Disappeared?

How Would College Basketball Look if the One-and-Done Rul...

Photo by David Williams / Redux for The New Yorker

Since its inception in 2006, the one-and-done rule, which requires that players spend a year in college or overseas before they can go into the NBA Draft, has been as divisive an issue as there is within basketball. The goal when this rule was established was to get high school players a little older and with more games of experience under their belts, even if they are on the professional level. The ramifications for college basketball, though, are potentially seismic if this rule were to disappear. Here are the potential effects on recruitment, conferences and team rosters, star development, and longevity relationships between college programs and NBA teams that the rule change can impact.

Recruiting and Enrollment of the Best HS Players

Broad Implications for Recruiting

The one-and-done rule requires that a player be at least 19 years old and out of high school for one year before entering the NBA Draft. College programs would be recruiting in a very different way. Coaches would have to start making stronger personal connections with some kids who might not agree to play even just one year at a college.

Competition for Elite Talent Turns Up: Schools would compete not just against each other but also against the NBA. They'd have to step up their recruiting pitch, discussing development for the pros and greater exposure.

An Abbreviated Recruitment Cycle: The recruiting cycle could be fast-tracked so that teams know the futures of players earlier on. Top recruits may choose this path rather than commit to a college filled with other top talent, leading to an even more volatile and mysterious recruiting landscape.

Effects on College Going in the Longer Term

That, in turn, could potentially sap the quality of elite players who ultimately choose to enroll in college basketball programs. Some top players might choose an alternative path by playing overseas or joining G League teams that offer competitive salaries while providing professional development opportunities.

Impact on College Basketball

Changes in Team Dynamics

Added Experience: Teams would be pretty veteran-heavy as the top prospects head directly to the draft or spend more time in college instead of being one-and-done. It may help create added competitive balance and allow teams to receive the development of older players at that stage when their optimal underclassman counterpart is now a professional.

Super Teams Could Emerge: Like in the NBA, programs that can recruit top-tier talent will be able to put together "super teams." Conversely, a small number of talent may instead flock to historically strong programs over time as an increased imbalance in the sport would result.

Impact on Game Quality

Improving Skills: More time in college would give players more opportunities to polish their skills, resulting in a better brand of basketball. The hope is that this could lead to better-produced and more tactically astute games, which would attract a larger viewing audience.

Longer Tenures: The idea is that the nation will become more familiar with each player and their journey through college, which would, in turn, increase rivalries between athletes based on how long they stayed at school.

Development and Workflows for Elite Players

Developmental-Learning Opportunities for Players

By eliminating the one-and-done rule, we would give elite players who could fully develop their game at college another option.

Players would have more time to develop fundamental skills and team chemistry, often missed in the rush to join the NBA. That error could build in a generation of professional players better equipped for top-league football.

Also, college programs could offer on-the-job training to young athletes through mentorship. Coaching staffs led by former players could act as role models. The advice would be important as they have to find their way through the difficulties of professional basketball.

Potential for New Pathways

The NBA could extend its G League or introduce additional development leagues to give the younger new talent an ideal setting for potential success in the main league. It might more accurately pave the way for players coming out of high school to sign pro basketball contracts.

One silver lining is that players would have the opportunity to recommit themselves to their academics and personal lives, which can lead to well-rounded careers after basketball.


SHOP Mystery Signed Memorabilia

LATEST

  • NEWS
  • |
  • ARTICLES
  • |
  • VIDEOS
img_articles

Why is the NCAA D1 Men's Basketball Tournament ...

img_articles

NBA Draft Insights: Duke's Rising Star Cooper F...

img_articles

Inside Cooper Flagg’s Family: Meet the Future D...

img_articles

Meet Ace Flagg: Cooper Flagg's Twin Brother

img_articles

Cooper Flagg's NIL Valuation: What You Need to ...

img_articles

Kentucky Basketball's Greatest Centers: A Legac...

img_articles

Hannah Stuelke's Parents: Mario and JoAnna's In...

img_articles

The 'One and Done' Rule in College Basketball: ...

img_articles

What is Reed Sheppard's Net Worth?

img_articles

Kentucky Wildcats' Basketball Championship Drou...

img_articles

Cooper Flagg: Tracing the Journey of a Basketba...

img_articles

Ace Bailey: The Making of a Future Basketball S...

img_articles

Dylan Harper: An In-Depth Look at His Basketbal...

img_articles

Liam McNeeley: The Rise of a Young Talent in Co...

img_articles

Drake Powell: A Comprehensive Profile of His Ba...

img_articles

VJ Edgecombe: Uncovering the Background of a Ri...

img_articles

AJ Dybansta: The Path to Prominence in the Worl...

img_articles

Cameron Boozer: A Deep Dive into His Rise in Co...

img_articles

What Does Caitlin Clark's Parents Do For a Living?

img_articles

What is Connor McCaffery's Net Worth?

img_articles

Braden Smith's NIL value at Purdue basketball

img_articles

A Deep Dive: Top 10 Players in College Basketba...

img_articles

Jared McCain's NIL value at Duke before joining...

img_articles

Juju Watkins: A Rising Star on the Cover of SLAM

img_articles

Dior Johnson: A Rising Star in College Basketball

img_articles

What Happened to NBA Prodigy Mikey WIlliams?

img_articles

Zach Edey: How Edey Transformed Purdue's Basket...

img_articles

The Tragic Night That Changed Bobby Hurley's Life

img_articles

Unveiling the Legacy: Who is Shaqir O'Neal, Son...

img_articles

The Impact of NIL in College Sports: Athlete En...

img_articles

Dennis Rodman and Annie Bakes: The Unconvention...

img_articles

What is Bronny James's Net Worth in 2024?

img_articles

What ethnicity is Dawn Staley?

img_articles

Top 10 Centers in College Basketball History

img_articles

Do any College Basketball Players have Signatur...

img_articles

Has a Men's College Basketball Team ever Had a ...

img_articles

Did Geno Auriemma ever play basketball?

img_articles

Who is the greatest college basketball coach of...

img_articles

Where is Zach Edey projected to be drafted?

img_articles

Bronny James Enters the Transfer Portal from USC

img_articles

Does Kim Mulkey have a daughter?

img_articles

Did Bobby Hurley ever Make it to the NBA?

img_articles

What is Bobby Hurley's Salary in 2024?

img_articles

Is Dan Hurley Related to Bobby Hurley?

img_articles

Are Duce and Dawn Staley related?

img_articles

Why Bryce James could be better than Bronny James

img_articles

Unveiling the Impact of DJ Burns on NC State Ba...

img_articles

Bronny James: A Decision Between College and th...

img_articles

Who is Oakland Basketball Player Jack Gohlke?

FAN ARCH PODCAST NETWORK

nothing

Mystery Signed Memorabilia

//script of featured and trending tab div