Is Caitlin Clark the Best Women's College Basketball Player in History?
By Jocelyn Alano September 29, 2025 18:29
In the pantheon of women's college basketball, few names ignite as much passion and debate as Caitlin Clark. The Iowa Hawkeyes guard, who wrapped up her collegiate career in 2024, shattered records, drew unprecedented crowds, and catapulted the sport into the mainstream spotlight. With 3,951 career points—making her the NCAA's all-time leading scorer across both men's and women's basketball—Clark's logo threes and no-look passes became cultural phenomena. But does statistical dominance and transformative influence make her the greatest ever? Or do championship pedigrees from legends like Diana Taurasi and Breanna Stewart hold more weight? As of 2025, with Clark thriving as a WNBA Rookie of the Year contender for the Indiana Fever, the conversation rages on. Let's break it down.
Caitlin Clark's Unprecedented College Legacy
Clark arrived at Iowa in 2020 as a highly touted recruit from Iowa's own Des Moines and quickly redefined what's possible for a women's college player. Over four seasons, she averaged 28.4 points, 8.2 assists, and 5.9 rebounds per game across 139 appearances, boasting the highest career scoring average (28.42 PPG) in Division I history. Her junior year in 2023 was a masterclass: 31.6 points per game, leading the nation in scoring and assists while guiding Iowa to its first Final Four since 1993.
The accolades piled up. Clark earned back-to-back Associated Press Player of the Year honors in 2023 and 2024, along with two Honda Sports Awards and the Honda-Broderick Cup as the nation's top female athlete. Iowa retired her No. 22 jersey—the third in program history—and she holds records for the most 30-point games (56) and triple-doubles (22) in women's NCAA history. Off the court, her "Caitlin Clark effect" boosted women's basketball viewership to record highs, with the 2024 NCAA championship game drawing 18.7 million viewers—more than the men's final.
Yet, for all her individual brilliance, Clark's Hawkeyes fell short of a national title, losing in the 2023 and 2024 finals to LSU and South Carolina, respectively. Does that asterisk diminish her case, or does her solo brilliance elevate it?
Stacking Up Against the All-Time Greats
To assess Clark's GOAT status, we must compare her to the era's undisputed queens. Recent rankings, like FOX Sports' August 2025 list, place her at No. 2 behind UConn's Breanna Stewart, with Diana Taurasi at No. 3. Other polls and experts often slot Cheryl Miller, Chamique Holdsclaw, and Candace Parker in the mix, but Taurasi and Stewart represent the championship blueprint Clark lacked.
Diana Taurasi, the "UConn Dynasty" architect from 2000–2004, was a scoring machine with guard skills that foreshadowed Clark's flair. She tallied 2,156 points, 648 assists, and 628 rebounds over three seasons (she redshirted one year), becoming the first Husky to hit 2,000 points, 600 assists, and 600 rebounds. Taurasi led UConn to three straight national titles (2000, 2002, 2004), earning two Final Four Most Outstanding Player awards and the Naismith Player of the Year in 2004. Her teams went 139-8, showcasing dominance in a less three-point-reliant era.
Breanna Stewart, UConn's 6-foot-4 forward from 2012–2016, is the gold standard for versatility and winning. She amassed 2,676 points—the second-most in Husky history—along with 1,178 rebounds, 367 assists, 345 steals, and 294 blocks. Stewart's junior year alone: 19.4 points, 12.8 rebounds, and 4.2 blocks per game. She powered four consecutive undefeated seasons and national championships (2013–2016), snagging three Final Four MVPs and two Naismith awards. UConn's 151-5 record under her watch? Untouchable.
Clark outscores both in raw totals and efficiency, but Taurasi and Stewart's rings—seven combined—tip the scales for many. As ESPN analysts noted in a March 2025 debate, Clark's era featured deeper talent pools and faster paces, inflating stats, while her predecessors thrived in more physical, defense-heavy games.
The Case For: Revolutionizing the Game
Proponents argue Clark isn't just great—she's revolutionary. Her scoring explosion (eclipsing Pete Maravich's men's record) and playmaking (sixth all-time in assists) happened on a stage she helped build. Women's Final Four attendance surged 288% during her career, and her Nike endorsement deal rivals male stars'. Sue Bird, a UConn legend, defended Clark in a March 2025 podcast, calling her "the most influential player ever" for inspiring a new generation.
Clark's style—deep threes, viral dimes—modernized women's hoops, much like Steph Curry did for the men's game. In a Quora thread from early 2024, fans highlighted her against-type success at Iowa, a non-blueblood program, versus the stacked UConn rosters. No other player has held NCAA scoring records across genders, and her two AP awards match Taurasi's haul. If "best" includes cultural impact, Clark's the frontrunner.
The Case Against: Championships Trump Flash
Critics, including FOX Sports' Skip Bayless and Rachel Nichols in April 2024, contend Clark falls short without hardware. Taurasi and Stewart didn't just shine—they won, often against elite competition. Clark's Hawkeyes, despite her heroics, posted a 92-27 record with zero Big Ten titles until her senior year. In contrast, Stewart's perfect seasons and Taurasi's dynasty runs embody total dominance.
Era adjustments matter too: The 2020s' emphasis on threes (Clark shot 387 career makes) versus the post-centric 2000s favors her stats. ESPN's July 2024 top-25 21st-century ranking omitted Clark entirely, prioritizing pros like Taurasi (still active in 2025). A Reddit thread from March 2025 echoed this: "Cheryl Miller or Brittney Griner edges her out—Clark's amazing, but not the GOAT yet." Her WNBA transition, while promising, hasn't erased the college title void.
The Verdict: In the GOAT Conversation, But Not Crowned Yet
Caitlin Clark is undeniably one of the greatest—perhaps the most electrifying—women's college basketball player ever. Her records may stand for decades, and her legacy as a game-changer is etched in history. But in a sport where team success often defines immortality, Taurasi and Stewart's championship hauls keep them atop most lists. As a YouTube debate from March 2025 put it, Clark's the "greatest attraction," but the GOAT throne requires more than highlights.
With Clark's WNBA stardom unfolding, this debate will evolve. For now, she's not the best—yet she's redefined what "best" can mean. In women's hoops, that's a win bigger than any trophy.
LATEST
- NEWS
- |
- ARTICLES
- |
- VIDEOS
FAN ARCH PODCAST NETWORK
