Rodgers to the Big Apple? Why Aaron Rodgers Might Be Heading to the New York Giants

By Jason Bolton March 06, 2025 22:29

The NFL offseason rumor mill is churning once again, and at the center of it all is none other than Aaron Rodgers. The future Hall of Fame quarterback, fresh off a disappointing two-year stint with the New York Jets, is reportedly eyeing a move across town to the New York Giants. This potential shift has sent shockwaves through the league, leaving fans and analysts alike speculating about the reasons behind this unexpected twist in Rodgers' storied career.

At 41 years old, Rodgers is far from the MVP-caliber player he once was, but his experience and leadership could be exactly what the Giants need. The team, coming off a challenging 5-12 season, is in desperate need of a steady hand at the quarterback position. With the No. 3 overall pick in the upcoming draft, the Giants might miss out on top quarterback prospects like Miami's Cam Ward and Colorado's Shedeur Sanders, making Rodgers an attractive short-term solution.

Giants general manager Joe Schoen hinted at the team's quarterback strategy during the NFL scouting combine, saying, "Even if you get a young quarterback, you'd like to have a vet in the room with him to show him the ropes and how to be a pro"1. This statement aligns perfectly with the idea of bringing in Rodgers as a mentor figure.

The rumor gained traction when NFL Network's Daniel Jeremiah dropped a bombshell on his "40s and Free Agents" podcast. "I don't know who the Giants are going to have at quarterback," Jeremiah said. "And I've had this conversation with a bunch of different people, and everybody says the same thing. It feels like Aaron Rodgers or bust"1.

Adding fuel to the fire, ESPN's Adam Schefter reported on February 28 that the Giants were "including" Rodgers in their search for a veteran quarterback during the offseason1. This news sent Giants fans into a frenzy, with many wondering if the four-time MVP could be the missing piece to their championship puzzle.

Financially, the move could make sense for both parties. Rodgers' current contract with the Jets includes a $37.5 million salary for 2025, with a cap hit of $23.5 million3. The Giants, while not flush with cap space, could potentially restructure Rodgers' deal to make it work within their financial constraints.

Peter Schrager of NFL Network offered his take on why this move could be beneficial for both Rodgers and the Giants. "The thought that [Rodgers] wasn't so bad last year, teammates like him, and he and Daboll kind of playing with a chip on both of their shoulders this year. Let's team up and let's do this thing together," Schrager said5.

However, not everyone is convinced that Rodgers to the Giants is a done deal. Maxx Crosby, the star defensive end for the Las Vegas Raiders, has been openly recruiting Rodgers to join him in Sin City9. This adds another layer of intrigue to an already complex situation.

As the NFL free agency period approaches, all eyes will be on Rodgers and the Giants. Will the veteran quarterback don the blue and white, or will he surprise us all with another unexpected move? Only time will tell, but one thing's for sure – the Aaron Rodgers saga is far from over, and the New York Giants might just be the next chapter in his illustrious career.