NFL Quarterback Carousel: Which Rookie Will Dominate Year 2 —Drake Maye, Caleb Williams, or Jayden Daniels?

By Jason Bolton June 10, 2025 09:11

The 2025 NFL season promises to be a defining year for the league’s most promising young quarterbacks. Among the standout sophomores, Drake Maye (New England Patriots), Caleb Williams (Chicago Bears), and Jayden Daniels (Washington Commanders) have captured headlines for their rookie campaigns and potential to ascend to elite status. As these quarterbacks enter their second year, the question looms large: who will dominate the NFL in Year 2?

Drake Maye: The Dual-Threat with Untapped Upside

Drake Maye’s rookie season was marked by flashes of brilliance amid growing pains. Selected third overall by the Patriots, Maye’s arm talent and athleticism drew comparisons to Justin Fields and Clayton Tune. Despite an inconsistent offensive line and limited weapons, Maye put up historic numbers early on. In his first two starts, he threw for over 500 yards and five touchdowns, joining Dan Marino as the only quarterbacks in NFL history to do so in their initial outings.

Maye’s scrambling ability is notable he scrambled on 10.8% of his dropbacks, second only to Jayden Daniels among rookies, averaging 9.0 yards per scramble, the highest among his peers. His aggressive style leads to high-risk, high-reward plays, reflected in a turnover-worthy play rate of 3.7%, higher than some of his counterparts. However, with the Patriots bolstering their offensive line and adding weapons like Stefon Diggs, Maye’s environment is improving, setting the stage for a steadier, more productive sophomore campaign.

Caleb Williams: The Franchise Savior in Chicago

Caleb Williams, the No. 1 overall pick, carries the weight of reviving a struggling Bears franchise. Known for his dynamic dual-threat capabilities, Williams amassed 93 touchdown passes and 27 rushing touchdowns in college, showcasing elite playmaking. His rookie season was a mix of promise and adversity, including a league-high 68 sacks, highlighting the need for better protection.

Williams flashed six games with a passer rating over 100, demonstrating his potential to be a top-tier NFL quarterback. His 3.9% turnover-worthy play rate matches Daniels, indicating a relatively low risk profile for a young, aggressive QB. With Chicago’s commitment to building around him and his own determination to “chase Tom Brady’s record,” Williams is poised for a breakout year if the Bears can improve offensively.

Jayden Daniels: The Poised Playmaker in Washington

Jayden Daniels took the league by storm, winning the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year and earning a Pro Bowl nod. He posted a 70.6 QBR, the fourth-highest in the NFL, and set a rookie record with a 69.0% completion percentage. Daniels’ strength lies in his rushing ability he scrambled on 13.6% of dropbacks, averaging 8.1 yards per run, making him the most mobile among the trio.

Washington’s new regime has built a strong supporting cast, aiming to stabilize a franchise that has cycled through quarterbacks for years. Daniels’ low turnover-worthy play rate of 1.7% underscores his efficiency and decision-making. If he continues his upward trajectory, Daniels could be an MVP candidate in 2025.

Who Will Dominate?

Each quarterback brings unique strengths. Maye’s raw talent and improved supporting cast could unlock a high ceiling. Williams has the physical tools and motivation to lead a turnaround in Chicago. Daniels’ poise and efficiency already set him apart as a polished playmaker.

ESPN’s analysis highlights Maye’s athletic upside and the Patriots’ improved offense as key factors for his growth. Meanwhile, CBS Sports notes Daniels’ challenge will be to elevate his game further to reach MVP-level impact. Williams’ path depends heavily on Chicago’s offensive line and coaching stability.

The sophomore quarterback class of 2025 is one of the most intriguing in recent memory. While Jayden Daniels enters the season as the proven rookie star, Drake Maye and Caleb Williams have the talent and circumstances to challenge for dominance. As the season unfolds, fans and analysts will watch closely to see which young signal-caller seizes the moment and establishes himself as the NFL’s next franchise quarterback.