The Evolution of the Game: Is the NBA Too Soft?

By Jason Bolton August 19, 2024 22:32

Photo by Gregory Shamus/Gett

Since its inception in 1946, the NBA has undergone numerous evolutions, each era defined by its unique characteristics. However, a recent narrative has gained traction among fans and analysts alike: the claim that the NBA has become "too soft" compared to the gritty, physical battles of the past. This raises the question of whether this perceived softness is a detriment to the game or a natural progression towards a more skilled and dynamic form of basketball. In this article, we discuss many of the same rule changes, player styles, and assist-title-based officiating as other content creators but place them in a wider conceptual framework around how the overall culture has shifted inside out with perception.

In the Olden Days: NBA's Rough Past

The NBA was a much more physical league in its early days. The 1980s and 1990s have been referred to as the Golden Age of physical basketball, but even some in that era say what they see now is not how it used to be despite teams like Detroit's "Bad Boys" Pistons being warmed solely on their toughness. At the time, the Detroit Pistons used a grinding style focused on hard-nosed defense and hacksaw fouls, often leading to altercations. It was a time of physically tough basketball, with guys like Bill Laimbeer and Dennis Rodman gaining infamous reputations for their roughhousing.

The Impact of Rule Changes

Several rule changes in the NBA were designed to enhance scoring and speed up play. Notable changes include:

Three-Point Line: When the three-point line was first introduced, offenses began to adopt a more four-around-one style.

24-second Shot Clock: This rule first appeared in 1954 and was instituted to speed up the game by restricting team time to shoot.

Additionally, foul rules were changed. In the late 1990s and early 2000s, the NBA became rife with physical play, and instances of hand-checking and illegal defense increased. Consequently, these rule changes were implemented to increase the offensive flow and reduce the number of stoppages in the play. Subsequently, scoring increased significantly, and the pace of the game became faster.

For example, in the 2018-2019 season, average points per game were 111.8 compared to 102.9 in 1999 at the end of the 2000 season. Therefore, most fans associate physicality decline with these rules, as players cannot tackle the opposing player or perform hard fouls. Each player's style during the 1990s was mixed with relatively poor shooting and too much physicality.

The modern NBA game is about skill and speed, and that change makes people think physicality has declined. Another reason often cited for the lack of physicality in the modern game is player style. Modern players have better handles and shots and the ability to jump, with many fighting as tall as most centers in earlier NBA eras. Meanwhile, all players prefer taking shots from 3 points.

Take a Hard Look at Officiating

The officiating in the NBA has also changed over time, working to keep games flowing and avoid physical altercations. One initiative from early this decade was known as "Respect for Game," designed to reduce demonstrative arguing on both ends and foster more common courtesy between players challenging calls. This change has increased the technicals for players who argue with referees or express frustration, another aspect that paints today's league as "softer."

Officiating a Faster Game

Officiating has also become more difficult as the tempo of play quickens. The new officiating world means referees must call bang-bang plays in a quicker, more volatile environment. The league has poured more resources into training and monitoring its officials, but there have been continued public complaints about missed calls or potential inconsistencies from fans and players. That scrutiny can make the game seem softer because guys are getting called for things that would've flown twenty years ago.

The Cultural Shift in the NBA

This shift, too, reflects our changing NBA culture, which attaches increasing importance to player health and happiness. Now, a longtime societal push towards safety in sports has made its way into the league through tougher sanctions for fights and altercations.

Impact of Social Media & Fan Participation

The NBA cannot afford to have a black mark on its image during the social media era. Clips of bad calls are inevitable, or even just clips making the players look like chumps and, subsequently, deny themselves anything close to a polite conversation with people at their local bar. The storyline is domesticated to fans chirping on Twitter and Instagram, complaining that players are soft. From the start of training camp to the final whistle, this fundamental identity is constantly being challenged, and with hardcore debate around every corner, feedback loops into an even more pervasive narrative of softness throughout all corners.

Perspective: We Need Both Toughness & Skill

Others insist that the NBA has gone soft, but it is important to acknowledge what the best basketball players have learned due to this adjustment. This more substantial focus on skill and speed has resulted in a better product for anyone watching, with the game opening up even further. Analytics has also revolutionized how teams play the game, focusing on taking only certain types of shots and practicality above all else.

A Return to the Physical

The physical improvements have come at a cost to some of the previous-era fans, but despite that, they have been worth it in many ways. Leagues such as the BIG3, focusing on a return to an old-school style of play, suggest that this yearning for physical basketball has been satisfied. Meanwhile, players and coaches complain that this is not football; physical play has been removed from a league smitten with injuries.

The NBA has drastically modified its rules, player styles, and culture. The thought that the league has gone soft is rampant, but we must consider how these changes fit. This transformation is one that the NBA has managed to do gracefully, taking advantage of the skill and entertainment while dealing with officiating and player safety.

As the league changes and grows, it will be important to find a middle ground between preserving physicality that has been such an element of basketball in years past and moving towards the speed and skill game seen today. There will undoubtedly be more of these conversations in the future as players and coaches grapple with a game that never stops evolving. In the end, maybe the NBA is too weak, but it comes down to a matter of opinion, and all people have their spin on things that make basketball so beautiful.

SHOP Mystery Signed Memorabilia

Mystery Signed Football 8x10 Photo

Regular price

$29.99

Regular price

Sale price

$29.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Baseball Jersey

Regular price

$69.99

Regular price

Sale price

$69.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Football Jersey

Regular price

$69.99

Regular price

Sale price

$69.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Baseball 8x10 Photo

Regular price

$29.99

Regular price

Sale price

$29.99

Unit price

per