Will the Raiders Regret Cutting Christian Wilkins? Inside the Fallout
By Jason Bolton July 28, 2025 12:03
The Las Vegas Raiders’ bold decision to release defensive tackle Christian Wilkins in July 2025 marks one of the most controversial and consequential moves of their offseason, raising questions about whether the franchise will come to regret cutting ties with the high-profile defensive lineman. Signed to a lucrative four-year, $110 million contract just last March, Wilkins’ tenure with the Raiders was swiftly cut short after just one injury-plagued season mired in disagreement between player and team over the treatment of a Jones fracture in his foot.
Wilkins, 29, played in only five games for the Raiders in 2024 before sustaining the injury, which prematurely ended his season. He initially underwent surgery, but the team wanted him to have additional foot surgery during the prolonged rehab process a step Wilkins declined, opting instead for a non-surgical rehabilitation route. This divergence led to increasing tension, with the Raiders eventually voiding the roughly $35.2 million of guaranteed money left on Wilkins’ contract, citing failure to maintain his physical condition as the rationale for voiding the guarantees. Wilkins promptly filed a grievance through the NFL Players Association challenging the team’s decision.
The Raiders publicly framed the release as a necessary step due to the lack of a “clear path or plan” for Wilkins’ return to play, emphasizing the organization’s “commitment to excellence on and off the field” and signaling a new culture under Coach Pete Carroll and General Manager John Spytek that demands full commitment and readiness from players. Carroll acknowledged the difficult nature of the decision: “We took a long time to make our decision… There was no evident route to his return, so we had to move forward”. This blunt approach demonstrates the Raiders’ shift towards a culture of accountability and prioritizing roster fluidity as they rebuild.
Statistically, Wilkins had a strong NFL track record prior to injury, registering a career-best nine sacks with the Miami Dolphins in 2023 and tallying 17 tackles and two sacks in his brief Raiders stint. His rare combination of power and quickness was anticipated to shore up the Raiders' defensive line alongside Maxx Crosby, especially given their challenging AFC West competition. Wilkins’ early exit leaves a notable hole in Las Vegas’ pass rush and run defense, forcing the team to turn to replacements such as Adam Butler who stepped into Wilkins' role last season and was re-signed and other emerging players fighting for snaps at defensive tackle.
From a broader perspective, the Raiders’ decision risks backlash if Wilkins rebounds strongly elsewhere or reaches a settlement with the NFLPA that underscores the validity of his grievance. There are ethical concerns too, as some bioethics experts question whether the Raiders’ insistence on surgery conflicts with the principle of player autonomy that is, the right of athletes to decide their own medical treatment without organizational overreach. This medical and contractual dispute could set important precedents for future injury negotiations in the NFL.
For the Raiders, the fallout is a mix of lost talent, roster instability, and a possible legal and public relations headache. Yet, the organization’s leadership appears resolute, signaling they prefer to “move on” rather than tolerate uncertainty. How the Raiders manage the defensive tackle void in this crucial offseason will reveal if this tough-love approach ultimately helps or hinders their competitiveness.
The Raiders’ cutting of Christian Wilkins after just one season and amid injury rehabilitation disputes is a gamble on their evolving team culture and roster strategy. While Wilkins’ absence creates a clear deficiency on defense, the front office’s message about accountability is unmistakable. Whether they will look back with regret depends on Wilkins’ future performance, the outcome of his grievance, and how Las Vegas reintegrates its defensive line. As Coach Pete Carroll stated, “Every practice is a chance for us. Each day reflects who we are and what we represent.” For now, Wilkins’ release is among the highest-stakes roster decisions defining the Raiders’ 2025 offseason.
LATEST
- NEWS
- |
- ARTICLES
- |
- VIDEOS
FAN ARCH PODCAST NETWORK
