What to make of the Colts benching Anthony Richardson?

What to make of the Colts benching Anthony Richardson?

What to make of the Colts benching Anthony Richardson?

Troy Taormina-Imagn Images

The Indianapolis Colts (4-4) announced this week that they will be benching 22-year old Quarterback Anthony Richardson ahead of their Sunday Night Football matchup against the Minnesota Vikings (5-2), in favor of the veteran Joe Flacco. What should fans make of this sudden and unexpected QB change? 

Joe Flacco is the better passer

Although Anthony Richardson can sure run the ball, Joe Flacco is a much better passer at this stage in their respective careers. Richardson's completion percentage of 44.4% is dead last among qualified passers, more than 20 points lower than Flacco's 65.7% rate that he accumulated during the two-and-a-half games he has played this season. 

Richardson has a similarly horrendus passer rating, sitting at 57.2, also the worst of all qualified QBs. Flacco's passer rating 102.2 

Perhaps the biggest difference, however, is their ability to score. Joe Flacco has thrown seven touchdown passes compared to one interception in three games. Richardson, meanwhile, has thrown four touchdown passes and seven interceptions in five games. Richardson has also rushed for a touchdown and lost two fumbles, giving him 5 total TDs and 9 total turnovers. The difference is massive. 

Richardson lost the locker room

Critics of the benching have pointed out that other great QB's (Peyton Manning, Dan Marino, Aaron Rodgers, Kirk Cousins, Tua Tagovailoa, Sam Bradford, Eli Manning, Jordan Love, ect...) have had slow starts to their careers before eventually picking it up and becoming stars. Some fans believe the Colts should have committed to the player they picked fourth overall in 2023, instead of turning to a veteran with no real future in the league. 

However, Richardson's fate may not be only because of his stats. In the third quarter of the Colts' 23-20 loss last Sunday to the Texans, Richardson tapped out of a drive on a third-and-long play. After the game, he admitted he left the game because he was "tired." 

That comment may not have sit well with his teammates. Insiders believe Richardson has lost the locker room in Indianapolis, which likely contributed to his benching. 

The Colts want to win now

The Colts are a talented team. Despite Richardson's struggles, they are 4-4 and believe they have the talent to compete for an AFC playoff spot. They lost by two points and three points in their two matches with the rival Texans, so the gap is clearly not far. 

There are 52 men on the team, not to mention coaches, staff, and management. They cannot afford to waste an entire season trying to develop Richardson, when they believe they can win now. 

Imagine being a 32-year-old lineman tasked with protecting Richardson on every play. How would you feel if he left the game because he was "tired?" Would you be more or less excited to protect him on the next drive, the next game, knowing that not only is he holding the team back, but he is actively struggling to stay energized during the game. 

This isn't the end for Richardson

Anthony Richardson is only 22 years old. It is very likely he will get a second chance to start. In a league where Baker Mayfield, Sam Darnold, Jimmy Garoppolo, Carson Wentz, Jared Goff, Sam Bradford, Kirk Cousins, Daniel Jones, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Derek Carr, Geno Smith, Jacoby Brissett, Jameis Winston, Marcus Mariota, Teddy Bridgewater, Tyrod Taylor, Case Keenum, Ryan Tannehill, and so many others have been given second chances and made the most of them, it is very likely Richardson will get another chance to start in this league. 

Perhaps sitting and learning is what's best for him. Look at guys like Jalen Hurts, Brock Purdy, Jordan Love, and Patrick Mahomes. None of them started until the end of their first season (or in Love's case, his fourth season). They all benefited from learning, so perhaps Richardson will do the same. 

Or perhaps his fate will turn out similar to Trey Lance, another high first-round pick who didn't play much in college. Lance has yet to get a second chance and was traded by the team that initially drafted him. Could this be a warning sign for teams not to draft QB's with only a year of experience in the first round? Perhaps. 

Takeaway

The Colts are a better team with Flacco than they were with Richardson, and this move makes them real playoff contenders. Richardson will surely get another chance, and this might work out for everyone long term. 


LATEST

  • NEWS
  • |
  • ARTICLES
  • |
  • VIDEOS
img_articles

Is this Josh Allen’s year?

img_articles

Wll Dan Campbell's aggressiveness haunt him in ...

img_articles

The top NFL Playoff Races to watch

img_articles

Who should coach the Dallas Cowboys in 2025?

img_articles

Meet Jaime, Coach Sean McDermott's wife

img_articles

What happened to Trevor Lawrence?

img_articles

Who's the worst NFL quarterback core ever?

img_articles

Jameis Winston, a case study

img_articles

Meet Tammie, Booger McFarland's wife

img_articles

Meet Angela Marie Daniel, DeMarcus Ware's wife

img_articles

How L'Jarius Sneed reshaped his family life

img_articles

Meet Kim, Mel Kiper's wife

img_articles

What's the update with Christian McCaffrey's in...

img_articles

Trevor Lawrence's injury timeline amid Jaguars ...

img_articles

Will the Falcons trade Kirk Cousins before 2024...

img_articles

Why doesn't Mack Hollins wear shoes at Bills pr...

img_articles

The Worst Super Bowl Hangover

img_articles

How similar are Deion Sanders and Brock Lesnar?

img_articles

Is Chiefs RB Isiah Pacheco single?

img_articles

Who is the tallest NFL quarterback in 2024?

img_articles

How much is Jerry Jones' mansion?

img_articles

How many real estate properties does Jalen Hurt...

img_articles

Is Tom Brady gay?

img_articles

What did Shannon Sharpe say about the Panthers?

img_articles

What is Patrick Mahomes' net worth?

img_articles

Meet Anesha Sanchez, Tyreek Hill's mom

img_articles

Why did Russell Wilson and Ashton Meem get divo...

img_articles

Is Mason Rudolph currently single?

img_articles

Jameis Winston's deep relationship with the Chr...

img_articles

Meet Jameis Winston's insanely athletic mom, Lo...

img_articles

How Zach Wilson's mom mold him into being an ou...

img_articles

Zach Wilson's 2024 net worth

img_articles

Did Julian Edelman and Jerry Rice's daughter date?

img_articles

JK Dobbins and injury, an unfortunate pair

img_articles

Meet Natalie Lock, Drew Lock's wife

img_articles

Meet Von Miller's girlfriend, Megan Denise

img_articles

Meet Patrick Mahomes' half-brother, Graham Walk...

img_articles

How much is Jay Cutler's net worth?

img_articles

Meet Tammy Bradshaw, Terry Bradshaw's wife

img_articles

Meet Megan Harpe, Vontae Davis' wife

img_articles

Meet CeeDee Lamb's mom, Leta Ramirez

img_articles

Meet Jake Browning's girlfriend

img_articles

How much is Travis Hunter's net worth?

img_articles

Simone Biles Calls Patrick Mahomes a 'Miracle W...

img_articles

Are Josh Allen and Hailee Steinfeld engaged?

img_articles

2021 was bad, but somehow the 2022 QB draft cla...

img_articles

What happened to Aaron Hernandez's dad?

img_articles

Daniel Jones and the Giants, a Situationship

img_articles

Is Geno Smith married?

img_articles

Meet Steve and Becca, Daniel Jones' Parents

FAN ARCH PODCAST NETWORK