Top 10 Toronto Argonauts of All Time: Some of the Best Canadian Football Players

By Jason Bolton July 15, 2024 15:00

Making a list of the 10 best players in Toronto Argonauts history is always an enjoyable assignment for any sportswriter. To this day, the Argos have a history that dates back more than 100 years to their founding in 1873 as they've seen numerous legends suit up for them in their iconic double blue jerseys. Today, we ride through time to find out the black and gold's elite athletes throughout history.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Toronto Argonauts (@torontoargos)

1. Doug Flutie - The Maestro

Doug Flutie's stellar performances from 1996-1997, leading the team to back-to-back Grey Cup victories, solidify his place as one of the greatest Argonauts of all time. His remarkable achievements, including four Most Outstanding Player (MOP) Awards, make him an iconic figure in the team's history.

2. Michael "Pinball" Clemons - The Heart and Soul

Pinball Clemons, a dynamic player and later a revered coach and executive, embodies the essence of the Argonauts. His infectious energy, remarkable leadership, and outstanding on-field performances have endeared him to fans and secured his status as a beloved icon in the team's folklore.

3. Joe Krol - The Prolific Playmaker

Joe Krol's exceptional skills and pivotal role in leading the team to Grey Cup victories in the 1940s make him an undeniable presence on this list. His impact on the field, coupled with his enduring legacy, cements his position among the Argonauts' elite.

4. Damon Allen - The Quarterback Extraordinaire

Damon Allen's illustrious career as a quarterback, culminating in a Grey Cup triumph in 2004, places him among the all-time greats in Argonauts' history. His remarkable longevity and remarkable achievements make him a cornerstone of the team's legacy.

5. Derrell Mitchell - The Explosive Receiver

Derrell Mitchell's electrifying performances as a receiver, including pivotal contributions during the 1996 and 1997 Grey Cup victories, earn him a well-deserved spot among the top 10 Argonauts of all time. His impact on the team's success is undeniable.

6. Mike "Pinball" O'Shea - The Defensive Stalwart

Mike O'Shea's stellar defensive prowess and unwavering commitment to the team make him a formidable presence in the Argonauts' pantheon of greats. His contributions as a defensive stalwart resonate through the annals of the team's history.

7. Ricky Ray - The Cool-Headed Commander

Ricky Ray's composed leadership and remarkable achievements, including leading the team to Grey Cup victories in 2012 and 2017, firmly establish his place among the top 10 Argonauts of all time. His impact as a quarterback is etched in the team's illustrious history.

8. Terry Greer - The Prolific Pass Catcher

Terry Greer's exceptional abilities as a receiver and his pivotal role in the team's success during the 1980s make him an integral part of the Argonauts' legacy. His remarkable contributions on the field earn him a well-deserved spot among the team's greatest players.

9. Joe Theismann - The Commanding Quarterback

Joe Theismann's impactful stint as the Argonauts' quarterback, leading the team to a Grey Cup victory in 1971, secures his place among the top 10 players in the team's history. His leadership and on-field prowess resonate through the team's illustrious journey.

10. Chad Folk - The Reliable Lineman

Chad Folk's unwavering dedication and pivotal role as a lineman in the team's success make him a noteworthy inclusion in the top 10 Argonauts of all time. His contributions to the team's enduring legacy are deserving of recognition.

In conclusion, the Toronto Argonauts have been graced by an array of exceptional talents throughout their rich history. The top 10 players highlighted here represent the epitome of excellence and have left an indelible mark on the team's storied legacy, captivating the hearts of fans and etching their names in the annals of Canadian football history.