T.J. Watt, the Pittsburgh Steelers’ star outside linebacker and defensive cornerstone, is once again under the microscope following an injury sustained during the 2024-25 NFL playoffs. Watt, who finished the regular season with 61 tackles, 11.5 sacks, and a league-leading six forced fumbles, was visibly hurt early in the Wild Card game against the Baltimore Ravens, raising concerns about his availability and the Steelers’ defensive prospects moving forward.
The injury occurred on the first play of the second half when Watt left the field holding his left arm, later revealed to be an elbow issue. Despite the setback, he returned to the game with his elbow taped, showing remarkable toughness. However, the injury compounded a series of ailments Watt endured late in the season, including a thumb injury and an ankle issue suffered in Week 15 against the Eagles. These nagging injuries contributed to a reduction in his snap count during the final stretch, with Watt playing fewer than 80% of defensive snaps in the last four games.
Watt’s importance to the Steelers cannot be overstated. A seven-time Pro Bowler and four-time first-team All-Pro, he is the engine of Pittsburgh’s defense and a key figure in their hopes for postseason success. His ability to pressure quarterbacks, disrupt plays, and force turnovers has been instrumental, as evidenced by his 27 quarterback hits and 19 tackles for loss in 2024 alone. Losing him, even temporarily, leaves the Steelers relying on less experienced players like Nick Herbig, Jeremiah Moon, and Alex Highsmith to fill the void.
The Steelers’ defense also faces challenges beyond Watt’s injury. Veteran defensive tackle Cameron Heyward suffered an injury during the same playoff game, further depleting the defensive front. This double blow raises legitimate questions about Pittsburgh’s ability to contain high-powered offenses, especially in critical postseason moments.
Despite these concerns, the Steelers remain committed to Watt’s long-term presence. Contract negotiations have been complex and drawn out, with Watt seeking a deal that reflects his elite status in an evolving pass-rusher market. Currently in the final year of his 2021 extension, Watt’s average annual salary of $28 million trails behind peers like Myles Garrett, who commands $40 million per year. The Steelers have expressed no intention to trade Watt, focusing instead on securing a new contract that would likely make him the highest-paid edge rusher in the league.
Steelers insiders emphasize that while Watt’s injury is a setback, the team’s offseason acquisitions including cornerback Jalen Ramsey, tight end Jonnu Smith, and veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers are designed to bolster the roster and offset such challenges. Head coach Mike Tomlin has historically emphasized “next man up” mentality, relying on depth and resilience to weather injuries. Still, Watt’s absence undeniably weakens the defense’s pass-rushing threat and leadership on the field.
In Watt’s own words from earlier in the season, “I’m going to do whatever it takes to get back out there and help this team win.” His grit and determination have been evident throughout his career, and the Steelers will lean heavily on that spirit as they navigate the 2025 campaign.
Ultimately, while Pittsburgh can compete without Watt, their ceiling is significantly higher with him healthy and on the field. The Steelers’ defense thrives on his disruptive presence, and the team’s championship aspirations hinge on Watt returning to full strength. As the season unfolds, all eyes will be on Watt’s recovery timeline and the Steelers’ ability to adapt in his absence.

