Saints QB Update: Tyler Shough Outplays Spencer Rattler In Preseason Opener

By Jason Bolton August 12, 2025 09:34

In the New Orleans Saints' 2025 preseason opener against the Los Angeles Chargers, rookie quarterback Tyler Shough made a compelling case to lead the team's quarterback race by outplaying Spencer Rattler. While the Saints fell 27-13, Shough's performance provided a glimpse of hope and potential for a team still searching for stability at the quarterback position.

Spencer Rattler started the game for New Orleans but struggled to find rhythm against a tough Chargers defense. In his first half of work, Rattler completed 7 of 11 passes for 53 yards without any touchdowns or interceptions. He added a modest 22 rushing yards but was sacked three times and also fumbled after being strip-sacked late in the first half. Despite utilizing his mobility well, including an 11-yard run on a critical third down, Rattler’s inability to sustain drives or generate points left some doubts. He exited the game just before halftime with the Saints failing to score under his helm during the opening series.

When Shough took over in the second quarter, the dynamic shifted. The 25-year-old second-round draft pick threw a team-high 22 passes, completing 15 for 165 yards along with a touchdown and an interception. Early in his debut, Shough endured a costly pick-six, with rookie Chargers cornerback Eric Rogers intercepting a pass and returning it 43 yards for a score. However, Shough showed resilience and bounced back with an impressive 54-yard touchdown strike to Mason Tipton that ignited the offense. He also managed to lead a drive that resulted in a field goal just before halftime.

Saints head coach Kellen Moore praised Shough's composure and ability to keep the offense moving despite the setback. “We’ll learn from the interception, we’ll learn from that one, we’ll grow, but his response was really valuable,” Moore said postgame. Moore also highlighted Rattler's mobility and situational awareness, but the overall offensive struggles under Rattler's first-half play were more noticeable.

Both quarterbacks dealt with pressure from the Chargers’ defense, with Shough being sacked twice and Rattler three times. The offensive line's overall protection was a concern, exacerbating the challenge for both young signal-callers. Despite some mistakes, Shough displayed better command and a more positive impact, catching the attention of fans and analysts alike.

The Saints’ quarterback competition is far from settled, but Shough’s showing in the preseason opener has narrowed the gap considerably. While Rattler boasts more experience with six starts last season, Shough's ability to respond positively after adversity and produce explosive plays suggests he may be edging ahead as the favorite. Analysts agree that the team’s Week 2 preseason game and training camp practices will be pivotal, but a growing sentiment is that Shough might be the best choice to lead New Orleans into the 2025 regular season.

With the Saints hosting the Jacksonville Jaguars next week, both Shough and Rattler will have another opportunity to showcase their skills and solidify their spots. As the quarterback battle intensifies, the Saints and their fans hope this competition uncovers a leader capable of steering the team back to playoff contention.

In summary, Tyler Shough outplayed Spencer Rattler in the Saints’ preseason opener with a strong 165-yard, one-touchdown performance highlighted by a deep touchdown pass and resilience after a pick-six. Although the team still faces challenges, Shough's promising debut has brought renewed optimism to the quarterback battle in New Orleans.