New York Giants’ Quarterback Battle: Can Rookie Jaxson Dart Unseat Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston?

By Jason Bolton June 15, 2025 10:39

The New York Giants enter the 2025 NFL season with a compelling quarterback battle that has fans and analysts buzzing. Rookie Jaxson Dart, the 25th overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, finds himself competing with veterans Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston for the starting job. While Wilson is expected to open the season as the starter, Dart’s presence signals a potential shift in the franchise’s future, raising the question: can the rookie unseat the seasoned quarterbacks and become the Giants’ long-term signal-caller?

Veteran Presence and Rookie Promise

Russell Wilson, acquired in the offseason, remains the presumed Week 1 starter. In a recent statement, Wilson emphasized that Dart’s arrival “doesn’t change” his approach, underscoring his readiness to lead the team while mentoring the rookie. Meanwhile, Jameis Winston, signed as a free agent, adds depth and experience to the quarterback room, serving as another valuable mentor for Dart’s development.

Jaxson Dart, however, is far from a mere bystander. The Giants traded up to select him, signaling their belief in his potential. Dart signed a fully guaranteed four-year rookie contract worth nearly $17 million, including an $8.97 million signing bonus, reflecting the team’s investment in his future. At Ole Miss, Dart thrived in a quarterback-friendly offense that emphasized play-action and run-pass options, but the NFL’s faster pace and complex defenses will test his adaptability.

Development Plan and Early Impressions

The Giants’ coaching staff, led by head coach Brian Daboll and offensive coordinator Mike Kafka, appears committed to a patient development approach. Daboll recently stated, “The process of developing a quarterback is just that. We’re going to do everything we can to develop him and bring him along.” This suggests a redshirt rookie year for Dart, allowing him to learn behind Wilson and Winston before taking on a larger role.

Yet, the NFL is unpredictable. GiantsWire’s recent coverage notes that the Giants face the NFL’s toughest schedule in 2025, and a string of losses could force Dart into action sooner than planned. Early minicamp reports are encouraging: Dart has impressed coaches and teammates with his arm talent, mobility, and competitive toughness. Highlights from 7-on-7 drills show a quarterback capable of making accurate throws under pressure.

Expert Opinions and Historical Context

Giants legend Phil Simms weighed in on the situation, advocating for Dart to see playing time during his rookie season. Simms recalled his own rookie year, where after a few games on the sidelines, he gained confidence and seized the starting role. “The perfect scenario… I wasn’t prepared to kick off the season. I was on the sidelines, and after about three games, I realized, ‘I think I’ve got it now,’” Simms said. His perspective underscores the potential benefits of giving Dart real-game experience to accelerate his growth.

Supporting Cast and Challenges

Dart will have reliable targets in Malik Nabers, who exploded for 1,204 yards on 109 receptions as a rookie in 2024, and Darius Slayton, a consistent if unspectacular receiver. However, the Giants’ offensive line remains a concern, with Andrew Thomas as the lone elite talent protecting the quarterback. Dart’s tendency to hold the ball longer could be risky behind this line, adding pressure to his decision-making process.

The Giants’ quarterback battle in 2025 is a delicate balance of veteran leadership and rookie potential. While Russell Wilson is the safe bet to start the season, Jaxson Dart’s talent and early progress make him a legitimate contender to take over sooner than expected. With the coaching staff’s commitment to development and the looming pressure of a tough schedule, Dart’s NFL debut may come before the year’s end.

As the Giants navigate this transitional phase, the question remains: can Jaxson Dart unseat established veterans and become the franchise’s quarterback of the future? If early signs hold true, the answer could be a resounding yes.