Justin Fields Faces Pivotal Season With Jets: Is His Future in New York at Stake?

By Jason Bolton June 13, 2025 11:54

The 2025 NFL season represents a critical juncture for New York Jets quarterback Justin Fields. After a tumultuous start to his career, marked by inconsistent play and multiple team changes, Fields now finds himself in a “prove-it” year that could determine whether he remains the Jets’ long-term answer at quarterback or becomes a transitional figure in a franchise desperate for stability.

Fields arrived in New York this offseason on a two-year, $40 million deal, following a stint with the Pittsburgh Steelers where he showed flashes of promise but ultimately lost the starting job. His rushing ability remains his standout attribute he rushed for over 1,100 yards in 2022, showcasing elite athleticism and playmaking outside the pocket. However, his passing game has been a source of concern. ESPN’s Dan Graziano recently highlighted that Fields “can’t have an ‘OK’ season; he needs to prove he’s so good the Jets don’t have to draft a quarterback in the first round in 2026”.

The Jets’ new head coach, Aaron Glenn, is building a culture emphasizing discipline and a physical, run-heavy identity. Fields has impressed during the 2025 mandatory minicamp, turning heads with his arm strength, pinpoint accuracy, and clutch playmaking. Glenn’s plan to maximize the talents of star receiver Garrett Wilson, who has been targeted heavily in drills, could provide Fields with the weapons necessary to succeed.

Despite this optimism, skepticism remains. Pro Football Focus ranked Fields 28th out of 32 starting quarterbacks heading into the season, citing inconsistency in his passing game as a major concern. His career completion percentage sits at 60.1%, with 40 touchdowns against 30 interceptions over three seasons. While his rushing ability adds a valuable dimension, NFL offenses require a quarterback who can consistently deliver through the air.

Fields’ record as a starter 9-8 with the Jets and 5-12 with the Bears reflects the challenges he’s faced, though it’s important to note that neither team provided ideal circumstances. His 2024 season with the Steelers was mixed; he completed 65.8% of his passes for 1,106 yards, five touchdowns, and one interception in 10 games, while rushing for 269 yards and five scores. The Jets are betting on his growth under Glenn’s leadership.

The pressure on Fields is palpable. The Jets’ front office has made it clear that while they have not ruled out Fields as their long-term starter, the relatively modest guaranteed money on his contract for 2026 means they won’t hesitate to move on if he fails to meet expectations. This “ultimate prove-it season” narrative frames every snap Fields takes in 2025.

Despite the stakes, Fields remains confident. After OTAs, he expressed optimism about the team’s potential, stating, “I think the sky’s the limit for this team, for this offense… We have all the guys we need, we have all the talent, so it’s really just going to come down to discipline and execution”. His positive mindset and work ethic could be key factors in his development.

In summary, Justin Fields’ 2025 season with the Jets is a defining moment. He must elevate his passing consistency and leadership to secure his future in New York. With a new coaching staff, a talented supporting cast, and a fresh start, Fields has the tools to succeed but the margin for error is slim. As the Jets aim to break their 14-year playoff drought, Fields’ performance will be central to whether the franchise’s quarterback question is finally answered or remains unresolved.