Jets Try Out Nathan Peterman: Quarterback Battle Heats Up

By Jason Bolton August 17, 2025 07:33

The New York Jets are intensifying their quarterback competition with a recent tryout for veteran quarterback Nathan Peterman, signaling that the quarterback battle behind starter Justin Fields is far from settled. This move comes as the team navigates injury issues and looks to solidify its depth chart before the 2025 NFL season kicks off.

Peterman, a 31-year-old former fifth-round pick of the Buffalo Bills in 2017, has had a journeyman career characterized by brief stints with multiple NFL teams, including the Raiders, Bears, Saints, and Falcons. Despite a rocky start highlighted by a five-interception game early in his career, Peterman has remained in the league due to his reputation as a knowledgeable and reliable practice squad player.

With the Jets facing the loss of backup Tyrod Taylor to arthroscopic knee surgery and rookie Brady Cook sidelined due to an ankle injury, the organization sought additional quarterback depth to support Justin Fields. On August 14, the Jets hosted tryouts for Peterman alongside C.J. Beathard, Tyreik McAllister, and Kole Taylor, all competing for spots in an increasingly thin QB room.

While Peterman’s statistical resume—he has career totals of 12 touchdowns and 20 interceptions, and a career completion percentage hovering under 60%—does not inspire confidence as a long-term solution, the Jets see value in his experience and film study habits. Analyst reports note that Peterman’s football IQ and locker room presence could provide intangible benefits during practice and in mentoring younger quarterbacks like Brady Cook.

Head coach Aaron Glenn acknowledged the need to evaluate every viable option. “We want guys who are ready to step in if called upon, whoever that may be,” Glenn said. “Depth is critical, especially at quarterback. Nathan and C.J. brought their best to camp, and we’ll make the decision that best serves the team’s interests.”

However, skepticism remains among fans and pundits alike about Peterman’s potential impact should he win the backup job. His previous outings as a starter were marred by turnovers and inconsistent play, contributing to a 1-4 record as a starter in the NFL. Still, many agree that the Jets’ priority is safeguarding Fields and avoiding reliance on inexperienced backups during crucial games.

Adding to the intrigue is the potential for the Jets to claim Giants quarterback Tommy DeVito should he be waived. DeVito’s familiarity with New York-area football and roster flexibility could make him a competing candidate, adding a layer of complexity to the Jets' quarterback battle.

Looking ahead, the Jets’ quarterback room remains in flux. Adrian Martinez, currently on a short-term contract, is also in the mix, but lack of regular-season experience means the Jets are keen on securing a veteran presence like Peterman to stabilize the backup role.

Nathan Peterman’s tryout with the Jets highlights the urgency and uncertainty surrounding the team’s quarterback depth in the wake of injuries. While unlikely to be a long-term solution, Peterman’s arrival potentially offers a stabilizing veteran option as the Jets work to protect their franchise quarterback. How this battle unfolds will be a key storyline as the preseason progresses and roster decisions loom.