Did the Colts make the right call to bench Anthony Richardson?

Did the Colts make the right call to bench Anthony Richardson?

Steve Roberts-Imagn Images/File Photo

After the Colts uninspiring 21-13 loss on Sunday Night Football, fans are asking the question, did the team make the right decision to bench young QB Anthony Richardson in favor of Joe Flacco? 

Sunday Night Struggles

Joe Flacco struggled against a tough Minnesota defense on the road on Sunday Night, and Colts fans were quick to pounce on head coach Shane Steichen for making the move to Flacco. 

Flacco threw no touchdowns and one interception, and the Colts struggled to move the ball and score points. They trailed 21-10 late in the game, and only managed a field goal with 30 seconds left due to a pass interference penalty. 

Kicking problems

The Colts did miss a field goal earlier in the game that Flacco set them up for. Perhaps had they made the kick, things would have gone differently. Instead of kicking a field goal and attempting an onside kick, the Colts would have had the ball down by eight with a chance to tie the game. 

QB Controversy

Despite his poor showing, Flacco still has a much better TD/turnover ration than Richardson. In four games, Flacco has seven touchdowns and two interceptions. Meanwhile, Richardson has five touchdowns and nine turnovers in six games. 

Does that mean Flacco is definitively better than Richardson? Not necessarily, but it's impossible to deny he has better stats. 

Long term plans

Many Colts fans are worried that the team is jeopardizing it's long-term plans by benching their 22-year old signal-caller. Richardson is believed to be the future of the franchise, while Flacco is 39. 

Fans might not care that Flacco is better; they want to see the kid play and develop. These fans might not care about making the playoffs in 2024 if it leads to long term success down the road. 

Next week

Next week, the Colts have another difficult game against the Buffalo Bills. If Flacco can lead them to victory, he will have secured his status as starter. But another loss could lead the Colts to turn back to Richardson. After all, he is the future. 


LATEST

  • NEWS
  • |
  • ARTICLES
  • |
  • VIDEOS
img_articles

Biggest Busts of the 2025 Fantasy Football Seas...

img_articles

Tom Brady Dating History: Gisele, Bridget Moyna...

img_articles

The New Era of NFL Fan Culture: How Young Stars...

img_articles

Bo Nix Throws Two Picks but Broncos Win Again M...

img_articles

Giants Just Fired Brian Daboll Mid-Season Who’s...

img_articles

Jonathan Taylor Drops 244 Yards in Germany and ...

img_articles

Why Are There So Many Injuries in the NFL? Caus...

img_articles

The Importance of Having Your Tickets for Live ...

img_articles

Kansas City Chiefs 2025 Season Watch: Players t...

img_articles

Remembering Doug Martin: The 'Muscle Hamster' L...

img_articles

Rico Dowdle's Breakout: Time for the Panthers t...

img_articles

Joe Flacco's Resurgence: Is It Enough to Propel...

img_articles

Who Has the Best Betting Odds to Win Super Bowl...

img_articles

Saquon Barkley’s Second Season In The City of B...

img_articles

Jordan Love's Net Worth in 2025: From Backup to...

img_articles

Who Are Jordan Love's Parents? The Resilient Fa...

img_articles

Should the Carolina Panthers Give Up on Bryce Y...

img_articles

Who Is Brock Purdy's Agent? The Man Negotiating...

img_articles

Is Brock Purdy a Product of the 49ers System? U...

img_articles

Will Michael Chandler and Conor McGregor Finall...

img_articles

Who Are Lamar Jackson’s Parents? The Family Beh...

img_articles

Who Represents Lamar Jackson? The Story Behind ...

img_articles

Brock Purdy's Dating History: From Iowa State S...

img_articles

Joe Burrow's College Career: From Buckeye Backu...

img_articles

Josh Allen: The MVP of Buffalo Wings – A Quarte...

img_articles

NFL Week 5: all the games you won’t want to miss

img_articles

Who Are Joe Burrow's Parents? Meet the NFL Lega...

img_articles

Why the Miami Dolphins Must Trade Tyreek Hill Now

img_articles

Jalen Carter’s Net Worth Soars: How the Eagles’...

img_articles

Micah Parsons’ Net Worth Skyrockets: How the Pa...

img_articles

Josh Allen’s Net Worth Soars: How the Bills’ St...

img_articles

Josh Allen’s Heroics Fuel Bills’ Stunning Comeb...

img_articles

Micah Parsons’ Blockbuster Trade to Green Bay: ...

img_articles

Jalen Carter’s Spitting Incident Mars Eagles’ S...

img_articles

Chiefs' Shocking Loss in Brazil Exposes Cracks ...

img_articles

What is Joe Burrow's Net Worth?

img_articles

Brittany Mahomes Net Worth 2025: Beyond Patrick...

img_articles

The Untold Story of Travis Kelce and Taylor Swi...

img_articles

The Underlying Legitimacy Issues of the Unprece...

img_articles

NFL London Games: The Push Behind European Expa...

img_articles

Tyreek Hill Fined $50K by NFL – Full Details an...

img_articles

What Is the NFL Fifth-Year Option? (2025 Guide ...

img_articles

Can You Vape at NFL Stadiums?

img_articles

Patriots Coach Mike Vrabel Unleashes Hunt for ‘...

img_articles

Giants Rookie QB Jaxson Dart Cleared After Inju...

img_articles

Is Lamar Jackson’s Foot Injury Scarier Than Rav...

img_articles

Inside Antonio Martinez’s $100K Lawsuit Against...

img_articles

Steelers’ Derrick Harmon Injured—What It Means ...

img_articles

Are the Chiefs Still the Team to Beat in the AFC?

img_articles

Cowboys Owner Jerry Jones Comments on Micah Par...

FAN ARCH PODCAST NETWORK