Did the Colts make the right call to bench Anthony Richardson?

Did the Colts make the right call to bench Anthony Richardson?

Did the Colts make the right call to bench Anthony Richardson?

Steve Roberts-Imagn Images/File Photo

After the Colts uninspiring 21-13 loss on Sunday Night Football, fans are asking the question, did the team make the right decision to bench young QB Anthony Richardson in favor of Joe Flacco? 

Sunday Night Struggles

Joe Flacco struggled against a tough Minnesota defense on the road on Sunday Night, and Colts fans were quick to pounce on head coach Shane Steichen for making the move to Flacco. 

Flacco threw no touchdowns and one interception, and the Colts struggled to move the ball and score points. They trailed 21-10 late in the game, and only managed a field goal with 30 seconds left due to a pass interference penalty. 

Kicking problems

The Colts did miss a field goal earlier in the game that Flacco set them up for. Perhaps had they made the kick, things would have gone differently. Instead of kicking a field goal and attempting an onside kick, the Colts would have had the ball down by eight with a chance to tie the game. 

QB Controversy

Despite his poor showing, Flacco still has a much better TD/turnover ration than Richardson. In four games, Flacco has seven touchdowns and two interceptions. Meanwhile, Richardson has five touchdowns and nine turnovers in six games. 

Does that mean Flacco is definitively better than Richardson? Not necessarily, but it's impossible to deny he has better stats. 

Long term plans

Many Colts fans are worried that the team is jeopardizing it's long-term plans by benching their 22-year old signal-caller. Richardson is believed to be the future of the franchise, while Flacco is 39. 

Fans might not care that Flacco is better; they want to see the kid play and develop. These fans might not care about making the playoffs in 2024 if it leads to long term success down the road. 

Next week

Next week, the Colts have another difficult game against the Buffalo Bills. If Flacco can lead them to victory, he will have secured his status as starter. But another loss could lead the Colts to turn back to Richardson. After all, he is the future. 


LATEST

  • NEWS
  • |
  • ARTICLES
  • |
  • VIDEOS
img_articles

2025 NFL Draft Recap Key Picks and Betting Impl...

img_articles

The 2025 NFL offseason is in full swing, bringi...

img_articles

The Best Quarterback-Wide Receiver Duo in the N...

img_articles

Did Deion Sanders Tank His Son’s Draft Value?

img_articles

Cam Ward vs. Will Levis: The Titans’ Quarterbac...

img_articles

Why Shedeur Sanders Will Become the Starting QB...

img_articles

Which Team Did the Best in Drafting in the 2025...

img_articles

Why Ashton Jeanty Should Be the #1 Pick in Fant...

img_articles

Abdul Carter’s Jersey Number Rejection: A Rooki...

img_articles

Nike Releases Special Sneakers for NFL Draft Pi...

img_articles

Breaking Down the Top Remaining Offensive Playe...

img_articles

First round feelings

img_articles

Top 10 NFL Players Who Like to Gamble

img_articles

NFL draft preview

img_articles

Top 10 Wide Receivers in the 2025 NFL Draft

img_articles

Top 10 Cornerbacks in the 2025 NFL Draft: Lockd...

img_articles

Top 10 Offensive Linemen in the 2025 NFL Draft

img_articles

Top 10 Cornerbacks in the 2025 NFL Draft

img_articles

Top 10 Running Backs in the 2025 NFL Draft

img_articles

A Deep Dive into Nico Iamaleava’s Transfer to UCLA

img_articles

Ashton Jeanty, where will he go?

img_articles

An undeserved retirement?

img_articles

Running it back

img_articles

The ideal position

img_articles

A thankless job

img_articles

One step forward, two steps backwards

img_articles

Lamar Jackson is so unserious

img_articles

Death of the chain gang

img_articles

Big Rule Changes

img_articles

Cricket Superstars from India and Pakistan Unit...

img_articles

Stefon the Great

img_articles

The New New Giants

img_articles

The Business of Jersey Patch Sponsors

img_articles

The NFL as E-Commerce Catalyst: Examining an Un...

img_articles

Xavier Restrepo: The Hidden Gem of the 2025 NFL...

img_articles

Why Malik Nabers Thrives with Jameis Winston Ov...

img_articles

Will Shedeur Sanders Really Refuse to Suit Up f...

img_articles

Giants Eyeing a Sanders Sighting: Is Shedeur He...

img_articles

Into the Fire

img_articles

Mile High Magic

img_articles

Is Cincy in trouble?

img_articles

Panthers Owner David Tepper's Bold Play in Chin...

img_articles

What’s the deal with Aaron Rodgers?

img_articles

How the Cowboys Stack Up Against the NFL's Top ...

img_articles

Is Tyreek Hill Sprinting Towards All-Time Top 1...

img_articles

The $100 million man

img_articles

A new league year

img_articles

Davante to LA

img_articles

Daniels to Deebo for six

img_articles

Rodgers to the Big Apple? Why Aaron Rodgers Mig...

FAN ARCH PODCAST NETWORK