Cleveland Browns Legends: Ranking the 10 Best Players to Ever Wear Brown and Orange

By Jason Bolton June 16, 2025 09:38

The Cleveland Browns boast one of the most storied histories in the NFL, rich with legendary players who have defined the franchise’s identity and success across generations. From dominant Hall of Famers who led the Browns to multiple championships to modern icons who embodied grit and leadership, Cleveland’s brown and orange have been worn by some of football’s greatest. Here is a definitive ranking of the top 10 best players in Browns history, blending their impact, statistics, accolades, and lasting legacy.

1. Jim Brown (1957–1965, FB)
Jim Brown is widely regarded as not only the greatest Brown but one of the greatest football players ever. In 118 games, Brown rushed for 12,312 yards and scored 106 rushing touchdowns, leading the league in rushing eight times. He earned three NFL MVP awards and was instrumental in Cleveland’s 1964 NFL Championship. Brown’s combination of power, speed, and toughness revolutionized the running back position and set a standard that still resonates today.

2. Otto Graham (1946–1955, QB)
Graham was the Browns’ field general during their dominant early years, leading Cleveland to 10 championship appearances in 10 seasons (AAFC and NFL combined), winning seven titles. Known for his intelligence, accuracy, and leadership, Graham’s impact was unparalleled. He retired with a then-record 57.6% completion rate and remains a Browns legend.

3. Lou Groza (1946–1959, 1961–1967, OT/K)
“The Toe” Groza was a rare dual-threat as both an offensive tackle and a kicker. He scored 1,608 points in his career and made four NFL championships with the Browns. Groza’s clutch kicking, including a championship-winning field goal in 1950, cemented his place as a franchise icon and Hall of Famer.

4. Ozzie Newsome (1978–1990, TE)
Newsome was a premier tight end known for his reliable hands and route-running. He holds Browns records in receptions and receiving yards and was a six-time Pro Bowler. Beyond his playing career, Newsome’s impact continued as a Hall of Fame executive, shaping Cleveland’s future.

5. Bernie Kosar (1985–1993, QB)
Kosar was the Browns’ leader during the 1980s, guiding the team to three AFC Championship games. He threw for 21,904 yards and 116 touchdowns in Cleveland, earning a Pro Bowl nod in 1987. Kosar’s poise and clutch performances made him a beloved figure in Browns lore.

6. Clay Matthews Jr. (1978–1993, LB)
Matthews was a defensive stalwart, known for his tackling and playmaking. He played 232 games for Cleveland, forcing 24 fumbles and intercepting 14 passes. His leadership and consistency anchored the Browns’ defense for over a decade.

7. Nick Chubb (2018–Present, RB)
One of the most explosive backs in Browns history, Chubb has rushed for over 6,500 yards and 48 touchdowns through 2023. A four-time Pro Bowler, his combination of power and speed has made him a cornerstone of the modern Browns offense.

8. Paul Warfield (1964–1969, 1976–1977, WR)
Warfield was a dynamic receiver with 5,210 yards and 52 touchdowns in Cleveland. A three-time Pro Bowler, his speed and route-running made him a deep threat and a key offensive weapon during his tenure.

9. Hanford Dixon (1981–1989, CB)
Dixon was a lockdown cornerback and a two-time Pro Bowler. Known for his physicality and leadership, he helped define the Browns’ defense in the 1980s and popularized the “Dawg Pound” fan culture.

10. Joe Thomas (2007–2017, OT)
Thomas was a model of consistency and dominance, starting 10,363 consecutive snaps the longest streak in NFL history. A seven-time First-Team All-Pro, Thomas protected the Browns’ quarterback with elite skill and leadership.

The Cleveland Browns’ greatest players embody a tradition of toughness, skill, and leadership. From Jim Brown’s transcendent dominance to Otto Graham’s championship pedigree and Nick Chubb’s modern excellence, these legends have shaped the Browns’ proud history and continue to inspire fans in Cleveland and beyond.