Cleveland Browns Four-QB Competition: Flacco, Pickett, Gabriel, and Sanders on the Roster Bubble

By Jason Bolton August 15, 2025 06:40

As the Cleveland Browns approach the 2025 NFL season, one of the most intriguing position battles is unfolding at quarterback. The Browns’ roster currently features a crowded quarterback room with Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett, Dillon Gabriel, and Shedeur Sanders all vying for a coveted spot. With limited roster spots available, this four-QB competition has become one of the tightest and most closely watched quarterback battles in the league.

Joe Flacco, the seasoned veteran, currently holds the position of the probable starter. Flacco, 38, has been a steadying presence for the Browns, delivering professional experience and leadership. Known for his strong arm and playoff pedigree, he provides a reliable backup plan amid the youth competing behind him. Flacco stated, “I know my role and I embrace it. I’m here to help the team win and mentor the young guys. Every snap is important, no matter the situation.”

Kenny Pickett, the 24-year-old second-year pro, represents the Browns’ future. Drafted in the first round in 2022, Pickett has shown flashes of playmaking but has struggled with consistency. His 2024 season featured 2,500 passing yards, a 60% completion rate, and 15 touchdowns. The coaching staff believes he can take the next step, but questions remain if he’s ready to secure a full-time starting job. Pickett himself said, “I’m focused on improving every day, earning my spot, and showing this team I can lead.”

Dillon Gabriel, a 25-year-old with limited NFL experience, is considered a wild card in this race. Gabriel possesses impressive athleticism and has flashed a quick release, but he’s relatively unproven against NFL speed. Nevertheless, he fits the mold of a backup QB who can inject mobility and keep defenses guessing. “I’m grinding every day,” Gabriel noted. “I want to prove I belong in this league and contribute in any way possible.”

Completing the quartet is Shedeur Sanders, the youngest at 23, who brings an intriguing blend of youth and potential. Son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, Shedeur has played only sporadically in relief roles but has displayed a strong work ethic and football IQ. Skeptics wonder if he can withstand the NFL’s physical and mental demands, but the Browns see value in his versatility and untapped upside. Sanders shared, “Coming from a football family, I’m hungry to make my mark and grow into whatever role the team needs.”

The Browns’ HC Kevin Stefanski faces a difficult but important decision. “Each of these QBs brings something unique,” Stefanski said. “Our goal is to build a roster that can push the team forward, be it through experience, potential, or versatility. The competition is fierce, and we encourage these guys to bring their best to camp.”

NFL teams typically carry only two or three quarterbacks on the active roster, making this four-QB fight especially pressing. Flacco's steady presence might secure him a spot, while Pickett’s future investment makes his retention likely. That leaves Gabriel and Sanders battling closely for the final slot or a practice squad position.

The Browns’ offense, which averaged 300.8 yards per game in 2024, depends heavily on finding a reliable signal-caller to maintain momentum. The quarterback who secures the backup or developmental role could see playing time sooner than expected given the rough nature of the NFL season.

The Browns QB competition is far more than a simple numbers game it reflects the delicate balance between veteran experience and future promise. As the preseason intensifies, expect each quarterback to showcase their strengths, with the final roster cut looming as the decisive moment.

Who will emerge from this crowded quarterback room as the Browns’ trusted signal-caller remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the competition has pushed all four to elevate their game in pursuit of a roster spot.