Browns’ Quarterback Mystery: Are They Hinting at a Surprising Plan for Shedeur Sanders?

By Jason Bolton June 12, 2025 09:40

The Cleveland Browns’ quarterback situation is shaping up to be one of the NFL’s most intriguing storylines heading into the 2025 season, with rookie Shedeur Sanders at the center of swirling speculation. After a surprising slide to the fifth round in the NFL Draft, Sanders has quickly made waves during minicamp and OTAs, flashing the playmaking ability that made him a star at Colorado. Yet, with four quarterbacks on the roster including veterans Joe Flacco and Kenny Pickett, and fellow rookie Dillon Gabriel the Browns face a pressing decision on how to manage their quarterback depth, and Sanders’ future could hinge on a surprising plan behind the scenes.

Sanders’ draft-day fall was unexpected given his pedigree and college production, but the Browns’ front office traded up to select him 144th overall, signaling belief in his potential. Early reports from camp indicate Sanders is impressing coaches with his arm talent and poise, though he has yet to receive significant first-team reps. Browns offensive coordinator Tommy Rees described the quarterback competition as “completely open,” emphasizing that the rotation is fluid and the evaluation process ongoing. “We have a good group of guys that push each other,” Rees said, “and by the time September rolls around, we’ll be ready to go.” Yet, Rees’ comments also underscore the uncertainty surrounding who will ultimately lead the offense.

Adding to the intrigue is speculation that the Browns could trade Dillon Gabriel, who was drafted earlier and has shown promise as a poised pocket passer. Analyst Kurt Benkert recently suggested Gabriel could be headed to the Miami Dolphins, who reportedly coveted him during the draft. If Gabriel is moved, it would clear a path for Sanders to rise in the quarterback hierarchy, signaling that the Browns see him as more than just a developmental project.

“Shedeur has flashed the playmaking ability that made him a star at Colorado,” Benkert noted, “and if Cleveland is willing to move Gabriel, it means Sanders is proving something behind closed doors.” This potential trade would mark a pivotal shift in the Browns’ quarterback plans, elevating Sanders from camp arm to legitimate contender for the starting job.

Sanders himself remains focused despite the challenges. After a strong throw during minicamp that drew applause, he said, “I have time to develop and mature. I’m just focused on getting better every day.” His calm demeanor and confidence have won praise from teammates and coaches, even as some analysts remain skeptical about his readiness for Week 1.

The Browns’ head coach Kevin Stefanski has been more reserved, refusing to publicly endorse any quarterback as the clear starter. This cautious approach reflects the team’s desire to keep options open while balancing the need for immediate success. Veteran presence from Flacco and Pickett offers stability, but the Browns’ future likely hinges on the development of their young signal-callers.

Ultimately, the Browns’ quarterback mystery may be resolved by a surprise trade that reshapes the depth chart, potentially positioning Shedeur Sanders as the face of the franchise sooner than many expected. With his talent and work ethic on display, Sanders could seize the opportunity if given the chance. As the Browns navigate this complex quarterback competition, one thing is clear: the 2025 season will be a defining moment for Sanders and the team’s long-term direction.