Bills and James Cook Far Apart in Contract Extension Negotiations

By Jason Bolton June 13, 2025 11:53

The Buffalo Bills and running back James Cook find themselves at an impasse as the 2025 NFL season approaches, with contract extension talks reportedly stalled and both sides far from an agreement. Entering the final year of his rookie deal, Cook’s future with the Bills remains uncertain amid a growing divide over his market value and the team’s willingness to meet his demands.

Cook, the Bills’ second-round pick in 2022, has emerged as one of the league’s most productive backs. Over the past three seasons, he has demonstrated a rare combination of rushing prowess and receiving ability, totaling 1,567 yards from scrimmage in 2023 and following up with 1,267 yards and 18 touchdowns in 2024, tying Derrick Henry for the AFC lead in scoring. His versatility as a dual-threat running back has made him a key component of Buffalo’s offense, complementing quarterback Josh Allen and the team’s dynamic passing attack.

Despite his on-field success, contract negotiations have hit a wall. According to multiple reports, including those from Bleacher Report and Sports Illustrated, the Bills and Cook were “never really close” to finding common ground on an extension. The Bills reportedly offered a deal in the neighborhood of $10 million per year, while Cook’s camp is seeking upwards of $15 million annually, a figure that would place him among the highest-paid running backs in the NFL.

Bills general manager Brandon Beane has been candid about the situation, emphasizing the team’s control over Cook’s contract for the 2025 season but signaling a willingness to let him play out the year before revisiting long-term options. “I think Jimbo is a pro. I respect him and love him to death,” Beane said. “I’m sure he’s going to want to come out and prove that value that he and his reps put on him. ‘Hey, let me show you, if we’re not there, I’m going to go out here and do it again.’”

Cook’s absence from the Bills’ voluntary offseason workouts and OTAs earlier this year fueled speculation that he was leveraging his position to push for a better deal or even orchestrate a trade. However, he reported to mandatory minicamp in June, signaling his commitment to the team for the 2025 season despite the unresolved contract status.

Financially, the Bills hold the upper hand. Cook’s rookie contract expires after the 2025 season, and the team can allow him to enter free agency in 2026 if no agreement is reached. This leverage has seemingly contributed to the team’s reluctance to meet Cook’s current asking price, especially given the volatile market for running backs and the Bills’ salary cap considerations.

The Bills have also reportedly begun scouting potential replacements for Cook, eyeing younger backs who could provide cost-effective production starting in 2026. This strategy underscores the team’s cautious approach to committing significant long-term resources to a position that has seen frequent turnover league-wide.

For Cook, the 2025 season represents a “prove-it” year to justify his contract demands and solidify his value. His performance on the field will be critical not only for Buffalo’s playoff aspirations but also for his bargaining position in future negotiations, whether with the Bills or another franchise.

The contract extension talks between the Buffalo Bills and James Cook remain far apart, with no immediate resolution in sight. While the Bills value Cook’s contributions, financial realities and strategic considerations have created a standoff. As the 2025 season unfolds, both sides will be watching closely, with Cook aiming to demonstrate his elite talent and the Bills balancing competitiveness with fiscal prudence. The coming months will be pivotal in determining whether this productive partnership continues or reaches an end.