Why is Steve Mazzagatti Infamous? Unpacking the Controversies Surrounding the Referee

Why is Steve Mazzagatti Infamous? Unpacking the Controver...

By Oliver Wiener August 23, 2024 13:36

Photo by @sherdog.com

Steve Mazzagatti often arises in mixed martial arts, with strong emotions behind it. A controversial figure in a sport for whom he has officiated many high-profile fights. He has been accused of bad judgment, poor decisions, and not looking out for the best interest or health & safety of fighters throughout his career. What follows is an article that details Mazzagatti and the controversies surrounding him, with background information and specific incidents that are more recognizable to most fans.

Background and Career

Steve Mazzagatti began his career in combat sports as a martial artist and trained extensively in Muay Thai before becoming an MMA judge. By his 2008 interview, he had reffed for about a dozen years, first Muay Thai and then K-1 kickboxing in the early '90s. Mazzagatti also began refereeing MMA when it came to Las Vegas in 2002.

This is particularly interesting because, like other televised event referees, Mazzagatti actually works for state athletic commissions that govern live events in most states, not promotions like UFC. This line is important to define the interlocking web of referees, promotions, and state athletic commissions in MMA.

Over his career, Mazzagatti has been involved in some very big fights, working UFC contests with a company that is at the top level in MMA. Yet his stretch was not without controversy, and White, the UFC President, has frequently had strong words for him.

Controversies and Criticisms

Perhaps the most prominent critic of Mazzagatti has been Dana White. UFC President Dana White has called Mazzagatti "the worst ref in the history of any fight business." Whatever the issue at hand, White has been especially harsh and quite frequent in his criticism of Mazzagatti.

Among the Common Criticisms of Mazzagatti:

Bad Ref: Mazzagatti was known to have little judgment when it came to refereeing his fights. He would step in too early or too late and make even worse calls that changed the outcome of games entirely.

Inconsistent Rulings: Many of his critics say that Mazzagatti is more like a traffic cop than an MMA referee.

Not Ensuring Fighter Safety: The most egregious charge is that Mazzagatti has, on occasion, failed to ensure fighter safety inside his cage.

Notable Incidents

There have been a series of incidents that, more than anything else, make Mazzagatti the most controversial ref in MMA:

Jon Jones vs. Matt Hamill (2009): Regarding Mazzagatti's debatable officiating, his handling of this fight is probably the most infamous. This only loss in his professional record is obtained, which disqualified Jones for using illegal "12-to-6" elbow strikes. Many people criticized the DQ as they thought it was harsh and felt he should have been given a warning.

Brock Lesnar: There was a time when Mazzagatti actually deducted a point from one of Brock Lesnar's fights. Mercifully, this is all that probably needs to be said about it. When asked about the incident, Mazzagatti defended his actions, saying, "I'm a referee; I look for fouls. I'm not watching a fight. Given the task, I did it. "

Excessive Clenching and Inaction: Dana White has criticized Mazzagatti and other referees for allowing fighters to spend excessive time trying to defend themselves on the ground. Although White did not mention Mazzagatti by name, his remarks following UFC 149 illustrated the point even more clearly after he said: "At what point do you go, 'Ok, there's no fight going on here. These people paid money. These guys are supposed to be fighting,".

The View of Mazzagatti and His Explanation

Critics be damned, Mazzagatti has stood by his tactics when it comes to officiating. He stressed this in interviews: 'Referees don't make the rules; they enforce them.' "Look, we do not make the rules. We enforce them. Our job is not to make the fight how a promoter wants it. It's the fighter's job. It's their show".

Mazzagatti, meanwhile, also said that referees are in the limelight too often and can not make mistakes. He described it as fighters: Sometimes they get subbed, or they get beat, and that's how it goes. ''We are regrettably situated in the public gaze. We can't see it all.'

However, Mazzagatti also pointed out that referees work for the athletic commissions, which oversee and sanction fights, not promoters like Dana White. He said: "You got to realize that I don't work for Dana, and we don't work for Dana. I am a public servant for both the fans and the fighters. I just want to ensure the guys have a nice, clean fight they are training for and anticipating."

Broader Implications

Keeping Fighters Safe: The primary function of a referee is to ensure that fighters are injury-free. Mazzagatti's critiques have typically resulted from his perceived inability to do this function, showcasing the significant reliance that must be placed on proper officiating within an athletic competition as potentially dangerous for many participants.

The integrity of the Sport: Sudden missteps from referees and judges can threaten MMA's integrity. Fighters, fans, and promoters alike have been left scratching their heads when referees enforce questionable decisions that significantly affect fight outcomes.

Regulatory Control: The continued employ of maligned referees such as Mazzagatti suggests a failure, and perhaps even an absence altogether, by athletic commissions to oversee the sport meaningfully.

Critiques: High-profile controversies and poor officiating at high-level events can lead fans to perceive MMA in a negative light, which could set the sport back as it adjusts toward mainstream acceptance and growth.

The Other Side of the Coin

High-pressure environment: Referees must make split-second decisions in high-pressure environments. A play that looks incorrect on a slow-motion replay can be difficult to judge live in real-time.

Enforcement of Guidelines (Jon Jones DQ): While few will argue that the Jon Jones disqualification was an egregious overreaction, in truth, all Mazzagatti did was enforce a rule in its letter.

The career of Steve Mazzagatti, longtime MMA referee, is a case in point regarding the intricacies and controversies involved with being an official in combat sports. UFC President Dana White often criticizes him, particularly in the wake of a few high-profile gaffes during his time at the helm.

Though Mazzagatti has consistently argued in favor of his method, stressing that the priority was always to keep fighters safe and maintain fairness in competition, critics continue to raise issues about how he rules inside the cage.

The Mazzagatti controversies, though low stakes in themselves, also highlight larger issues dealing with referee training and accountability, as well as the relationship between officials and both promotions/athletic commissions. As the sport of MMA continues to take its place alongside boxing, these are likely only going to grow and become more prominent in future discussions regarding how it is run.

In the end, Steve Mazzagatti is more of an enigma than a significant figure in MMA. While the validity of that reputation remains a subject of debate to this day, there is little doubt that Mazzagatti's career has outsized discussions regarding how refereeing and officiating should play out in MMA.

SHOP Mystery Signed Memorabilia

Mystery Signed Football 8x10 Photo

Regular price

$29.99

Regular price

Sale price

$29.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Baseball Jersey

Regular price

$69.99

Regular price

Sale price

$69.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Football Jersey

Regular price

$69.99

Regular price

Sale price

$69.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Baseball 8x10 Photo

Regular price

$29.99

Regular price

Sale price

$29.99

Unit price

per