UFC 317: Alexandre Pantoja’s Legacy and the Flyweight GOAT Debate

By Ali Hammad July 01, 2025 04:14

Alexandre Pantoja’s dominant submission victory over Kai Kara-France at UFC 317 on June 28, 2025, further solidified his legacy as one of the greatest flyweights in UFC history and intensified the ongoing debate over the flyweight division’s GOAT (Greatest of All Time). With his fourth successful title defense since capturing the belt in 2023, Pantoja is carving out a record-breaking career that challenges the long-held supremacy of Demetrious Johnson, the division’s former king.

A Commanding Performance at UFC 317

From the opening bell at the T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, Pantoja (30-5) showcased why he is considered one of the pound-for-pound best fighters in MMA. He immediately took down Kara-France and neutralized the New Zealander’s striking threat with superior grappling control. After methodically advancing position, Pantoja secured a rear-naked choke in the third round, forcing Kara-France to tap out and retaining his flyweight title with authority.

This victory marked Pantoja’s 14th UFC flyweight win, setting a new divisional record for most victories, surpassing Demetrious Johnson. He also leads the flyweight division in finishes (8) and submissions (6), underscoring his well-rounded and relentless skill set.

The GOAT Debate: Pantoja vs. “Mighty Mouse”

Demetrious Johnson’s reign as flyweight champion from 2012 to 2018 set a high bar, with his record 11 consecutive title defenses and technical mastery. However, Pantoja’s recent accomplishments have sparked debate about whether he can surpass Johnson’s legacy.

While Johnson’s dominance was characterized by technical precision and innovation, Pantoja’s style blends aggressive striking with elite grappling, making him a more dynamic finisher. His ability to evolve and improve with age now 35 has impressed fans and analysts alike.

Pantoja himself remains humble about the comparison. “In many other weight classes, I would already be considered one of the all-time greats,” he said after UFC 317. “But I respect what Mighty Mouse did. I’m focused on continuing to defend my belt and keep building my legacy”.

What’s Next: Joshua Van and Beyond

Following UFC 317, Pantoja was immediately confronted by rising star Joshua Van, who had just secured a thrilling win over Brandon Royval in a fight many are calling a “Fight of the Year” candidate. Van, 23, is on a five-fight winning streak and has quickly risen through the flyweight ranks.

Pantoja acknowledged Van as a formidable challenger, saying, “He’s young, motivated, and technically sound. I believe he will be my toughest opponent yet. I’m ready to go back to the gym and prepare like a challenger, not just the champion”.

The UFC has already indicated that Van will be next in line for a title shot, setting up a compelling matchup that could further define Pantoja’s reign and the flyweight division’s future.

Potential Superfights and Legacy Building

Beyond the immediate title defense, Pantoja has expressed openness to unique superfights, including a potential catchweight bout against bantamweight champion Merab Dvalishvili. Such a fight, possibly for a special “BMF” title, would be unprecedented and could elevate Pantoja’s status even further.

Alexandre Pantoja’s performance at UFC 317 was not just another title defense it was a statement that he is firmly in the conversation as the UFC flyweight GOAT. By breaking records for wins, finishes, and submissions in the division, and by continuing to evolve as a fighter, Pantoja challenges the legacy of Demetrious Johnson and pushes the flyweight division into a new era.

With a promising challenger like Joshua Van on the horizon and the possibility of high-profile superfights, Pantoja’s reign is poised to be one of the most exciting chapters in UFC history. As he himself said, “I’m no longer just the world champion I’m the challenger every day.”