Justin Gaethje’s next opponent remains one of the most anticipated matchups in the UFC lightweight division, as “The Highlight” positions himself for another shot at the title. After his hard-fought unanimous decision win over Rafael Fiziev at UFC 313 in March 2025, Gaethje has made no secret of his desire to challenge for the lightweight championship, currently held by Ilia Topuria. However, the path to that title bout is anything but straightforward.
Gaethje, with a professional MMA record of 26-5, has long been one of the most exciting and dangerous fighters in the division. Known for his relentless pressure, knockout power, and willingness to engage in brutal wars, he has earned multiple Fight of the Night bonuses and a reputation as a fan favorite. His recent victory over Fiziev reaffirmed his status as a top contender, and he has publicly expressed his hope to face Islam Makhachev, the former champion and a dominant grappler, in a title fight slated for June 2025. “I am hoping it’s Makhachev,” Gaethje stated in a recent interview, underscoring his readiness to step into the octagon with the best in the division.
Yet, the lightweight landscape has shifted dramatically. Ilia Topuria claimed the vacant lightweight title at UFC 317 with a first-round knockout of Charles Oliveira, adding a new dynamic to the division. Despite Gaethje’s eagerness, Topuria has openly dismissed the idea of facing Gaethje next, instead expressing a preference for “new blood” in the division. Topuria’s manager and UFC insiders have indicated that Gaethje is still the closest contender to a title shot, but the champion’s reluctance complicates the matchmaking.
Gaethje’s frustration has been palpable. After UFC 317, where Topuria won the belt, Gaethje threatened retirement if he wasn’t granted a title opportunity soon. UFC President Dana White called Gaethje’s retirement talk “wacky” and challenged him to follow through if serious. Meanwhile, Topuria has favored a matchup with Paddy Pimblett, who has a history with the champion and recently received a title shot opportunity over Gaethje. This snub has only intensified the drama surrounding Gaethje’s next fight.
Despite the politics, Gaethje remains undeterred. His longtime rival and fellow lightweight contender Dustin Poirier voiced support for Gaethje’s claim to a title shot, highlighting his consistent performances and electric fighting style. “To me personally, I would pick Gaethje. A guy who’s done everything he’s done with the company, and put on the shows, it’s must-watch TV every time he’s out there,” Poirier said.
Other potential opponents include Arman Tsarukyan and Charles Oliveira, both ranked contenders who could serve as stepping stones to a title fight. Gaethje’s striking accuracy (60%) and high volume of significant strikes landed per minute (7.46) make him a formidable challenge for anyone in the lightweight top five. However, his history of two losses in previous title fights adds pressure to make the most of this opportunity.
Justin Gaethje’s next opponent is still undecided, but the stakes could not be higher. Whether he faces Islam Makhachev, Ilia Topuria, or another top contender, Gaethje’s relentless style and championship aspirations ensure that his next fight will be a must-watch event. As the lightweight division continues to evolve, Gaethje stands ready to remind the UFC why he remains one of the most thrilling fighters in the sport.

