Chael Sonnen’s Controversial Pick for UFC Fight of the Year: Fans React

By Ali Hammad July 09, 2025 09:30

UFC legend and analyst Chael Sonnen stirred the MMA world recently with his mid-year pick for the 2025 UFC Fight of the Year, sparking a wave of debate among fans and pundits alike. Sonnen selected the co-main event clash between Merab Dvalishvili and Umar Nurmagomedov at UFC 311 as his top fight, a choice that surprised many given the stacked calendar of thrilling bouts this year.

The Dvalishvili-Nurmagomedov matchup, which took place earlier this year, was a frenetic display of relentless wrestling and grappling prowess. Both fighters are known for their high pace and durability, and the fight lived up to that reputation with non-stop action across five grueling rounds. Sonnen praised the bout for its intensity and technical mastery, stating, “A star was made in that fight. It wasn’t just about fireworks; it was about heart, skill, and a true display of MMA at its core”.

However, Sonnen’s pick quickly became a lightning rod for controversy. Many fans expected more high-profile or dramatic finishes to claim the Fight of the Year honor. For example, the brutal knockout battle between Ilia Topuria and Charles Oliveira, which UFC Hall of Famer Daniel Cormier recently called the best KO of 2025 so far, was widely favored by the community for its electrifying finish and stakes. Others pointed to fights featuring marquee names or title implications as more deserving.

Social media buzz reflected the divided opinions. One fan tweeted, “Dvalishvili vs. Nurmagomedov was a war, but Sonnen’s pick ignores some of the more exciting and impactful fights this year.” Conversely, supporters of Sonnen’s choice argued that the fight’s technical depth and sheer competitiveness made it a classic beyond just highlight-reel moments. MMA analyst Christian Gallardo remarked, “Sometimes Fight of the Year isn’t about flash but about grit and skill. Sonnen’s pick highlights that perspective”.

Sonnen himself, a former top contender in both the light heavyweight and middleweight divisions, is no stranger to controversy. Known for his outspoken personality and sharp analysis, he has built a reputation as one of MMA’s most respected and polarizing voices. His career, spanning from his UFC debut in 2004 to his later Bellator fights, has been marked by memorable battles and candid commentary.

The debate around Fight of the Year selections is nothing new in MMA circles, where criteria often vary between fans, fighters, and analysts. Some prioritize dramatic finishes and highlight-reel moments, while others value technical skill, heart, and back-and-forth competitiveness.

Despite the backlash, Sonnen’s pick has reignited discussions about what truly defines a great fight. It also underscores the diversity of MMA styles and the appreciation for bouts that showcase wrestling and grappling as much as striking.

In the end, Sonnen’s controversial choice serves as a reminder that Fight of the Year honors are subjective and can highlight different facets of the sport. Whether fans agree or disagree, the Dvalishvili vs. Nurmagomedov fight has undoubtedly left a mark on the 2025 MMA landscape, and Sonnen’s endorsement has brought it renewed attention.

As the year progresses, the UFC will continue to deliver memorable fights, and the final Fight of the Year decision will likely remain a hot topic among fighters, analysts, and fans alike. For now, Sonnen’s pick has sparked a lively debate that reflects the passion and complexity of the sport he helped popularize.