Top 10 NFL Cards to Buy Now: Best Picks for Collectors and Investors

By Jocelyn Alano June 23, 2025 10:51

The NFL trading card market in 2025 is thriving, fueled by a combination of legendary players, rising stars, and limited-edition releases. For collectors and investors looking to maximize returns, selecting cards that blend rarity, player potential, and cultural significance is key. Here’s a rundown of the top 10 NFL cards to buy now, supported by recent sales data and expert insights.

1. Patrick Mahomes 2017 Panini Prizm Rookie Card #269

Patrick Mahomes remains the gold standard for NFL card investments. His 2017 Panini Prizm rookie card, especially in high grades, consistently commands premium prices. With multiple MVP awards and a Super Bowl title, Mahomes’ card recently sold for upwards of $1 million. As the Kansas City Chiefs continue to be contenders, his card’s value is expected to hold strong.

2. Tom Brady 2000 Playoff Contenders Championship Ticket Autograph #144

Tom Brady’s iconic 2000 Playoff Contenders autograph card is one of the most valuable football cards ever sold, fetching over $3 million in recent years. Brady’s unparalleled career, including seven Super Bowl wins and five Super Bowl MVPs, cements this card as a must-have for serious collectors.

3. Justin Herbert 2020 National Treasures Platinum NFL Shield Autograph (#1/1) #158

Justin Herbert’s 1-of-1 2020 National Treasures Platinum NFL Shield autograph card sold for $1.8 million, highlighting the demand for rare, high-end rookie cards of promising quarterbacks. Herbert’s strong performances with the Chargers make this card a top investment pick.

4. Jayden Daniels 2024 Select XRC Rookie Card #502

Jayden Daniels’ 2024 Select XRC rookie card is gaining traction due to his dynamic play style and rushing ability reminiscent of Lamar Jackson. Projected stats for 2025 include nearly 4,000 passing yards and 750 rushing yards, making his card a compelling speculative buy.

5. Caleb Williams 2024 Panini Prizm Rookie Card

Caleb Williams, a standout from the 2024 draft class, is generating buzz for his dual-threat quarterback skills. His Panini Prizm rookie cards are expected to appreciate as he matures in the NFL, making early investments in his cards promising.

6. Drake Maye 2024 Panini National Treasures Rookie Card

Another top rookie from 2024, Drake Maye’s National Treasures cards are sought after for their limited print runs and Maye’s potential as a franchise quarterback. Collectors are advised to watch his development closely.

7. Kyler Murray 2019 National Treasures Crossover Rookie Patch Autograph #1

Kyler Murray’s 2019 National Treasures rookie patch autograph card sold for $96,000 in 2022. Murray’s dual-threat capabilities and Pro Bowl appearances make this card a valuable asset, especially in high-grade condition.

8. Joe Burrow 2020 Donruss Optic Downtown Gold Vinyl #40

Joe Burrow’s 2020 Donruss Optic Downtown Gold Vinyl card, limited to just five copies, sold for $108,000. Burrow’s leadership and consistent performance with the Bengals continue to drive demand for his cards.

9. Shedeur Sanders 2025 Panini Prizm Football Hobby Box Cards

Shedeur Sanders, a dynamic quarterback prospect from Colorado, is among the top players to watch in 2025. His cards from the Panini Prizm set are expected to rise in value as his NFL career unfolds.

10. Travis Hunter 2025 Panini Prizm Football Hobby Box Cards

Travis Hunter’s versatility as a wide receiver and cornerback makes his 2025 Panini Prizm cards highly collectible. His dual-threat ability and college success have collectors anticipating his professional impact.

Why These Cards?

According to sports card analyst Megan Cooper, “Cards that combine limited print runs, superstar potential, and cultural relevance consistently outperform the market.” Grading quality is essential, with PSA 9 and 10 cards commanding the highest prices. The rise of digital marketplaces has also expanded access, increasing liquidity and demand.

The NFL card market in 2025 offers a wealth of opportunities for collectors and investors. From established legends like Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes to promising rookies such as Jayden Daniels and Caleb Williams, these ten cards represent the best blend of rarity, player potential, and market momentum. Investing in high-grade examples and limited parallels remains the best strategy to maximize returns as the NFL season progresses.