What If the 2004 Detroit Pistons Never Beat the Lakers?

By Arslan Saleem August 09, 2024 01:48

Photo by Paul Sancya, AP

Imagine a world where stories unfold differently, where underdog tales don’t always end in triumph, and the expected champions fulfill their narratives. This presents an intriguing alternative history in the realm of professional basketball, particularly focusing on a pivotal moment that could have reshaped its legacy: What if the 2004 Detroit Pistons never managed to secure their stunning victory against the Los Angeles Lakers in the NBA Finals?

Together with Fan Arch, let's embark on a journey through this imagined reality, exploring the far-reaching implications and altered narratives that might have unfolded if the Lakers had reigned supreme in 2004, continuing their dynasty and altering the course of basketball history as we know it.

2004 NBA Finals Background

In 2004, the NBA Finals saw an epic collision of two teams known for their defense: the Detroit Pistons and superpower Los Angeles Lakers, fourth title in five years. The Lakers were a star-studded team with Shaquille O'Neal, Kobe Bryant, Gary Payton, and Karl Malone, while the Pistons ground through by committee with Chauncey Billups, Ben Wallace, and Rasheed Wallace. Coming out of the regular season, doubters abounded as Detroit posted a 54-28 record to earn its way into The Finals.

The Pistons beat the Lakers in a huge upset, and moments like this had no precedent. And they did something as no team ever had won a title without an all-time great player, flipping the prevailing notion that every championship side must have at least one legendary caliber talent with which to accomplish this. The Pistons were buoyed by their stalwart defense, which neutralized the high-scoring Lakers and exhibited a masterful game plan put into action by coach Larry Brown.

What It Would Mean If The Lakers Win

Key Players' Legacies

Had the Lakers won the championship, many historical records and career reputations would have inevitably been altered. First, Shaquille O'Neal, who already possessed three championships, would have become an even more formidable center due to his fourth title. The chances are that he would be regarded as one of the top five players in basketball history, whereas now, opinions are divided regarding his status as one of the best.

Second, Kobe Bryant, although exceptionally young for the third title, would have effectively altered his career narrative if the Lakers had won in 2004. He could end up with six titles when it's all said and done, tying his idol, Michael Jordan, in ring count.

The Hall of Fame standards to which he would have been judged if the Lakers had won the championship would also become more agreeable to his qualifications if he had more victories than he currently has. The situation is quite the opposite regarding the Pistons' legacies, with the team's key players not destined to reach the Hall of Fame.

With a loss, the probability of players such as Billups and Wallace would be decidedly lower, as memorability in the NBA is directly connected with titles achieved. The probability would have become more negative with a victory taking a significant role in their career narrative.

NBA Landscape

If the Lakers had won in 2004, half of the NBA would have changed the competitive landscape. Teams may have shied away from pouring resources into reloading for years, speculating the Lakers would continue to dominate.

More importantly, the Lakers' success has driven player movement and free agency decisions. Star players might have been likelier to take a chance on the Lakers, counting LA as their best shot at gold. This would have solidified the Lakers dynasty and lessened other franchise opportunities to contend for championships.

Narratives and Perceptions

Storylines for both the Pistons and Lakers would have been altered entirely. Despite the Pistons being known for their team play and defense, it would be seen as a squad that didn't reach its full potential. Their out of nowhere triumph in 2004 would be remembered as the product of luck, not a real toast run.

Meanwhile, the Lakers would have been praised as a juggernaut, proving that elite talent is needed on your team to win championships. This mentality directly affected team building post-2004, as teams could favor star players above all else to the detriment of chemistry and defense.

The alternate reality of what could have been had the 2004 Detroit Pistons not beaten down on the Los Angeles Lakers is a tale that can only be heard and never fully quantified in professional sports. The fact that the Pistons eventually overcame insurmountable odds for one of the biggest upsets in NBA history serves as a testament to perseverance, but think about what had taken place and how just one detail could have shifted league dynamics, altering it forever.

SHOP Mystery Signed Memorabilia

Mystery Signed Football 8x10 Photo

Regular price

$29.99

Regular price

Sale price

$29.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Baseball Jersey

Regular price

$69.99

Regular price

Sale price

$69.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Football Jersey

Regular price

$69.99

Regular price

Sale price

$69.99

Unit price

per
Mystery Signed Baseball 8x10 Photo

Regular price

$29.99

Regular price

Sale price

$29.99

Unit price

per