Yankees Planning Fire Sale? Insiders Reveal Who’s Really on the Trading Block

By Oliver Wiener June 19, 2025 09:40

As the 2025 MLB trade deadline approaches, speculation is mounting that the New York Yankees may be gearing up for a significant roster shakeup. Despite the franchise’s perennial championship aspirations, insiders suggest that the Yankees could be preparing a fire sale, moving key veterans and even some young talent to reset the roster and address pressing needs.

At the center of these rumors are four notable players: Giancarlo Stanton, Marcus Stroman, Anthony Volpe, and Devin Williams. Each faces unique circumstances that make them potential trade candidates, fueling speculation about the Yankees’ strategy heading into the crucial summer stretch.

Giancarlo Stanton: Injury Concerns and a Changing Lineup

Giancarlo Stanton, the veteran designated hitter, has yet to appear this season due to persistent elbow injuries. His absence has opened the door for emerging hitters like Ben Rice, whose strong performances have made Stanton’s roster spot less secure. According to Zachary Howell of Clutch Points, the Mariners have shown interest in Stanton once he regains full health, making him a prime candidate to be moved.

Stanton’s injury history and hefty contract make him a logical trade chip for the Yankees, who might seek to shed salary while acquiring younger, cost-controlled assets. His career numbers 325 home runs and a .273 batting average still command respect, but the Yankees appear ready to pivot toward a more sustainable lineup.

Marcus Stroman: Injury and Contract Implications

Pitcher Marcus Stroman’s injury status complicates his future with the Yankees. Currently sidelined and unable to trigger his 2026 player option, Stroman’s uncertain health makes him a trade candidate. The Yankees may prefer to move him now rather than risk losing him in free agency or carrying an expensive contract with limited on-field contributions.

Stroman has been a reliable arm when healthy, posting a 3.82 ERA over 1,200 career innings. His departure would leave a gap in the rotation but could free payroll for other acquisitions.

Anthony Volpe: Young Talent in a Potential Swap

Anthony Volpe, the team’s promising shortstop, has also been linked to trade talks, particularly in a potential deal involving Atlanta’s Ozzie Albies. While Volpe’s youth and upside make him a valuable asset, the Yankees’ lack of a solid backup at shortstop complicates any trade scenario.

Volpe’s 2025 season has been solid, with a .275 batting average and 15 home runs, but the Yankees may view a swap as a way to bolster other areas of the roster.

Devin Williams: Bullpen Depth Under Review

Relief pitcher Devin Williams, who has been a key piece in the Yankees’ bullpen, is also reportedly on the trading block. The Yankees’ recent roster moves and injuries have forced them to reassess bullpen depth, and Williams’ value on the market could help the team acquire needed pieces.

Yankees’ Strategic Outlook

While the term “fire sale” often implies a wholesale teardown, the Yankees appear more focused on strategic adjustments. According to MLB.com, pitching remains a top priority for the Yankees at the deadline, suggesting that any trades will aim to improve the rotation and bullpen rather than purely offload salary.

General Manager Brian Cashman has not publicly confirmed any trade plans but has acknowledged the team’s need to remain flexible. “We’re always evaluating how to improve the roster,” Cashman said in a recent interview. “Our goal is to build a team that can compete now and in the future.”

The Yankees’ rumored trade activity reflects the complex balancing act of managing veteran contracts, injury risks, and roster needs. Giancarlo Stanton’s injury-plagued season, Marcus Stroman’s uncertain health, and the potential movement of young players like Anthony Volpe underscore a franchise at a crossroads.

As the trade deadline nears, fans and analysts will watch closely to see if the Yankees commit to a bold roster overhaul or opt for incremental changes. Either way, the moves made in the coming weeks will significantly shape the Yankees’ pursuit of postseason success in 2025 and beyond.