Reds Outslug Mets 8-4 in Queens as Late Rally Falls Short for New York

By Oliver Wiener July 21, 2025 09:43

In a thrilling offensive display at Citi Field on Sunday, the Cincinnati Reds outslugged the New York Mets 8-4, extending their recent dominance over the Mets and handing New York a tough loss despite a late rally that ultimately fell short. The victory marked the Reds’ fourth consecutive win over the Mets in this series, highlighting their ability to seize control early and maintain momentum against a team fighting for playoff positioning.

Cincinnati’s offense came alive early and often, spearheaded by dynamic play from Elly De La Cruz, who went 3-for-4 with two RBIs and a run scored. De La Cruz sparked many pivotal rallies, including a first-inning single that scored the game’s opening run. The Reds set the tone quickly, as first baseman Matt McLain contributed a run-scoring single in the third inning, and Tyler Stephenson grounded into a key run-scoring forceout later in the game, showcasing the Reds’ aggressive yet effective approach at the plate.

“This team has been clicking lately,” Reds manager Mike Brown explained. “Our guys are taking good pitches and making the most of their opportunities. That early run really helped set the tone for us.”

The Mets fought back valiantly, buoyed by solid performances from Juan Soto and Pete Alonso. Soto smacked a crucial RBI single in the third inning, vaulting New York briefly ahead, while Alonso contributed multiple hits and drove in two runs during the contest. Despite their efforts, the Mets’ offense was hampered by a lack of productivity with runners in scoring position, finishing just 1-for-10 in those situations a critical factor in the outcome.

“We had some chances to keep that rally going, but timely hitting just wasn’t there tonight,” Mets manager Paul Keller commented. “Credit to Cincinnati’s pitching and defense; they made us pay when it mattered most.”

On the mound, the Reds’ pitching staff outperformed expectations. Starter Nick Martinez earned the win by pitching five innings and allowing just two runs while striking out five. His steady presence limited damage and kept the Mets’ bats from gaining sustained traction. Relievers Clay Holmes and Emilio Pagán shut down any late Mets threats, with Pagán securing his 21st save by inducing crucial strikeouts in the ninth to seal the victory.

One of the most dramatic moments came in the ninth inning when the Mets loaded the bases with two outs, setting the stage for a potential comeback. However, Juan Soto’s drive on a pitch that was closely ruled a check-swing strike three halted the rally, punctuated by Pete Alonso’s flyout to the right-field warning track to end the game. The tense finish exemplified the tightly contested nature of the series.

Despite the loss, New York remains in playoff contention with a 55-44 record, trailing division leaders by just 1.5 games. Meanwhile, Cincinnati improved to 52-47, reasserting themselves as a strong presence in the competitive National League Central with a renewed confidence fueled by this series sweep.

Looking ahead, the Mets are set to host Andrew Abbott in their next outing, hoping to get back on track, while the Reds will look to carry their momentum forward with their versatile rotation in upcoming games.

Sunday’s 8-4 slugfest was a testament to Cincinnati’s balanced offensive attack and resilient pitching. It underscored the Reds’ ability to rise to the occasion against tough opponents while highlighting New York’s struggles with timely hitting. This series will be remembered as a crucial juncture in both teams’ seasons, with Cincinnati seizing the upper hand in their ongoing NL rivalry.