Hunter Greene’s Injury Setback: How Will It Impact the Reds’ Playoff Hopes?

By Oliver Wiener July 09, 2025 09:30

The Cincinnati Reds received troubling news on July 7, 2025, as their ace pitcher Hunter Greene experienced a setback in his recovery from a right groin strain. Originally expected to begin a rehabilitation assignment with Triple-A Louisville on July 8, Greene reported tightness following a bullpen session, forcing the Reds to delay his rehab start and prompting an MRI to rule out further damage. Manager Terry Francona confirmed the postponement, emphasizing a cautious approach: “We’re going to take it day by day with Hunter. His health is our priority”.

This latest development is a significant blow to the Reds, who have been relying on a rotation that has struggled to find consistent dominance in Greene’s absence. Greene, the second overall pick in the 2017 MLB Draft, had been on track for a second consecutive All-Star appearance before the injury sidelined him. Through 11 starts in 2025, he posted an impressive 2.72 ERA with 73 strikeouts over 59 2/3 innings, demonstrating his role as the staff’s clear ace and a key factor in Cincinnati’s playoff aspirations.

The injury timeline has been frustratingly drawn out. Greene first landed on the injured list on June 4 with a Grade 1 groin strain. He returned briefly after the minimum 15-day stint, making three appearances before being removed early on June 3 due to discomfort. The Reds had hoped for a timely return after the All-Star break, but the recent setback clouds that outlook, with no firm timetable currently in place.

From a strategic standpoint, Greene’s absence puts increased pressure on the Reds’ rotation depth. Cincinnati currently sits in a competitive Wild Card race in the National League Central, and the presence of their ace could be the difference-maker in tight late-season contests. Francona acknowledged this, stating, “Hunter gives us a chance to win every fifth day. Without him, it’s a tougher road”.

Statistically, Greene’s value is evident. His strikeout rate and ability to limit runs have been among the best on the team, and his presence stabilizes the rotation. The Reds’ other starters have shown flashes but lack the consistency Greene brings. Without him, the bullpen faces heavier workloads, increasing the risk of fatigue and diminished effectiveness as the season progresses.

Greene himself remains optimistic but realistic. Speaking to reporters, he said, “I felt strong before this, but the body sometimes has its own plans. I’m focused on getting healthy and coming back better. It’s frustrating, but I’ll take it one day at a time”. His measured approach reflects maturity and leadership, qualities that have endeared him to teammates and fans alike.

Looking ahead, the Reds must balance patience with urgency. Rushing Greene back risks aggravating the injury, potentially sidelining him longer. Yet, the playoff window is narrow, and every game counts. The medical staff’s cautious stance, coupled with Greene’s day-to-day monitoring, suggests a careful rehabilitation process will be prioritized.

Hunter Greene’s injury setback represents a critical challenge for the Cincinnati Reds as they chase postseason success. His absence weakens an already fragile rotation, complicating the team’s path in a tightly contested division. However, Greene’s talent and resilience remain a beacon of hope. If he can return to form, the Reds’ playoff hopes will be significantly bolstered. Until then, Cincinnati must navigate the stretch with depth, determination, and a bit of patience.