The St. Louis Cardinals find themselves at a pivotal crossroads as the 2025 trade deadline approaches, grappling with whether to trade rising star Lars Nootbaar or remain committed to him as a cornerstone of their future. This decision carries significant implications for a franchise striving to balance competitiveness with a necessary roster rebuild following the departure of longtime leader Paul Goldschmidt.
Goldschmidt’s exit last offseason left a glaring leadership void and offensive hole. The seven-time All-Star and former NL MVP signed with the Yankees, where his early-season surge (.327 average, six homers, .859 OPS in 220 at-bats) highlighted what the Cardinals lost. Internally, however, the team viewed this transition as an opportunity to elevate younger talent. That responsibility quickly turned to 28-year-old Lars Nootbaar, who has taken strides as a middle-of-the-order bat and clubhouse presence.
The dilemma is stark. On one hand, Nootbaar's consistent 2025 performance career-highs in batting average and slugging positions him as a clear heir apparent in the Cardinals’ lineup. From a clubhouse standpoint, sources say teammates and management increasingly look to Nootbaar for leadership, marking him as “untouchable” amid trade talks. His emergence eases the blow of losing Goldschmidt, giving the team a viable offensive weapon without the costly contract burdens Goldschmidt carried.
Yet, the Cardinals remain at a crossroads because of external market pressures and organizational priorities. With their payroll close to $180 million and $111 million committed next season, the Cardinals face tough financial decisions. They must weigh whether to preserve payroll flexibility for pitching acquisitions or to invest further in offensive talent. As a result, some insiders speculate that the team could consider packaging Nootbaar in a deal, especially to address pitching deficiencies. The Cardinals’ struggles with bullpen and starting rotation depth have been well-documented, making pitching a top priority.
Moreover, there are trade rumors swirling around other veterans. Third baseman Nolan Arenado, though still productive, has been linked to potential trade talks amid rebuilding murmurs. Some analysts argue the Cardinals should “blow up” the roster and trade veterans like Arenado and even younger pieces if the right offers arrive. This context amplifies the tension around Nootbaar, whose value in the trade market is higher than any other young Cardinal.
In an ESPN report, the question around the Cardinals’ direction was framed succinctly: "Are they rebuilding or trying to compete now?" The uncertainty about Nootbaar’s trade status symbolizes this broader identity crisis. The front office must decide if they trust their young core’s development or if they seek an infusion of pitching through trades even at the cost of offensive talent.
Managerial voices suggest patience. One front office source told The Athletic, “We believe in what Lars can bring long term, on and off the field. Moving him would only make sense if it’s the right package to bring back impact arms.” Such a stance points to a deliberate, cautious approach that places player development and clubhouse stability ahead of risky deadline gambles.
In summary, the Cardinals face a defining moment with Lars Nootbaar. Holding him affirms a path anchored around young talent and offensive continuity, while trading him might accelerate a rebuild with pitching upgrades but risks alienating fans and players alike. As July 31 nears, St. Louis must reconcile the desire to remain competitive with the practical demands of financial management and roster construction. Whether they trade or hold, this decision will shape the Cardinals’ trajectory for seasons to come.
LATEST
- NEWS
- |
- ARTICLES
- |
- VIDEOS
FAN ARCH PODCAST NETWORK
