Aaron Judge Set to Return: How Will Yankees’ Lineup Change Tonight?

By Oliver Wiener August 06, 2025 09:33

Aaron Judge is set to return to the New York Yankees lineup tonight after a 10-day absence due to a right flexor strain in his elbow, a development that could significantly impact the struggling Bronx Bombers as they try to halt a recent skid . The reigning American League MVP, who leads the majors in batting average (.342), on-base percentage (.449), slugging percentage (.711), and OPS (1.160), is expected to resume his role as designated hitter initially, with his return to the outfield to come later once his throwing program progresses .

Yankees manager Aaron Boone expressed enthusiasm about Judge's return, emphasizing the slugger's importance to the team both offensively and in the clubhouse. Boone said, "It's Aaron Judge -- we know what he means to our lineup, to the guys in the room. So to get him back, we're certainly excited about that. And then hopefully, shortly thereafter, he's back out in the field, too". However, Boone also cautioned that Judge would begin gradually, starting with playing catch and monitoring his arm's response before any active defensive play, with the outfield return possibly aligning with the upcoming home series against the Astros.

While Judge did not play in the field last game, he participated in batting practice and took live at-bats at the Yankees' minor league complex in Tampa to prepare for tonight's game. His return ends a 4-6 stretch during his absence, a period where the Yankees were swept by the Marlins and struggled offensively, posting just a .231/.311/.399 slash line without their star hitter. Boone's remarks and the team's record during Judge's time on the injured list underscore how critical Judge is to the Yankees' offensive production and overall competitiveness.

In terms of lineup adjustments, Judge is expected to bat third in the order, reestablishing the Yankees' usual heart-of-the-lineup strength. With second baseman Gleyber Torres having left a recent game due to groin tightness and ongoing defensive challenges Torres leads the majors with 11 errors this season the Yankees may also shuffle other positions as they integrate Judge back. Oswaldo Cabrera and DJ LeMahieu have recently been shifting positionally to cover infield spots, indicating the Yankees are balancing lineup durability with maximizing offensive output.

From a performance standpoint, Aaron Judge has been on a historic pace this season, widely regarded as one of the most dominant hitters in Major League Baseball. His ability to combine power and average has him in the conversation for another MVP-caliber campaign. Judge himself acknowledged the spotlight that comes with this role, saying, "It's part of the role, part of being the Yankees' captain... I prefer to shoulder that burden rather than someone else". His return bolsters the Yankees not just statistically but as the emotional and leadership center of the clubhouse.

In summary, Aaron Judge’s return tonight primarily as designated hitter will re-energize a Yankees lineup that has faced offensive struggles in his absence. The lineup will slot him back to his familiar No. 3 spot, potentially strengthening run production and protection for the rest of the order. Manager Aaron Boone plans to ease Judge back into full playing duties cautiously, prioritizing his health and long-term availability. With the Yankees battling a multi-game losing streak and seeking to maintain their edge in a tight AL East race, Judge’s presence could be the spark needed to turn things around .