The Enduring Legacy of Bart Starr: Exploring the Top 5 Most Expensive Card Sales

The Enduring Legacy of Bart Starr: Exploring the Top 5 Mo...

By Jocelyn Alano July 19, 2024 14:58

As a sports writer, I give you my top picks for the most exciting Bart Starr collectibles on the market right now. The Hall of Fame quarterback who won five NFL titles - including the first two Super Bowls bears an indelible imprint on football and has made his collectibles a hot commodity among diehard fans as well as shrewd collectors.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Green Bay Packers (@packers)

1957 Topps Bart Starr Rookie Card #119 - $288,000

Let's start with the crown jewel of Starr's collection - his 1957 Topps rookie card. This timeless piece is a true testament to the quarterback's rise to greatness. Graded a PSA 9, this card is an exceptionally rare find, with only three out of the 2,335 cards ever produced achieving this lofty status.

In 2017, this remarkable card made headlines when it sold for a staggering $288,000 at a Heritage Auctions event. The sale price underscores the immense value collectors place on Starr's early career, as this card serves as a tangible connection to the quarterback's formative years and the dawn of his Hall of Fame journey.

1960 Topps Bart Starr #51 - $4,200

Moving on, we have the 1960 Topps Bart Starr card, which has also commanded impressive prices in the collector's market. Graded a PSA 9, this card sold for $4,200 at a Heritage Auctions event in November 2022.

What makes this card so desirable is its scarcity - out of the 1,377 cards graded by PSA, only 29 have achieved the coveted Mint 9 status. This rarity, combined with Starr's enduring legacy, has made this card a must-have for serious collectors seeking a piece of football history.

1959 Topps Bart Starr #23 - $4,440

The 1959 Topps Bart Starr card is another gem in the quarterback's collection, with a PSA 9 grading fetching an impressive $4,440 at a Heritage Auctions event in January 2023. Similar to the 1960 Topps card, the 1959 edition is also highly condition-sensitive, with only 29 out of 1,492 cards achieving the Mint 9 status.

This card's allure lies in its ability to transport collectors back to the dawn of Starr's illustrious career. As the Packers' signal-caller, Starr's impact on the game is undeniable, and this card serves as a tangible link to that era, making it a coveted addition to any football card enthusiast's portfolio.

1968 Topps Bart Starr #1 - $3,000

The 1968 Topps Bart Starr card, graded a PSA 9, is another standout in the quarterback's collection. This card sold for $3,000 at a Heritage Auctions event in January 2023, further solidifying Starr's status as a true icon of the game.

What makes this card particularly special is its scarcity - out of the 1,097 cards graded by PSA, only 28 have achieved the Mint 9 status, with a single card even earning the elusive Gem Mint 10 grade. This rarity, combined with Starr's enduring legacy, has made this card a highly coveted item among collectors.

1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr #82 - $425

Rounding out our top 5 is the 1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr card, which sold for $425 on eBay in January 2024. While not as valuable as the previous entries, this card still holds significant appeal for collectors due to its historical significance and Starr's undeniable impact on the game.

The 1967 Philadelphia set is a beloved classic among football card enthusiasts, and Starr's inclusion in this collection adds an extra layer of desirability. With only 529 cards graded by PSA and none achieving the Gem Mint 10 status, this card's scarcity and connection to a true legend of the sport make it a worthy addition to any collection.

As we've explored, Bart Starr's football cards have become true treasures in the collector's market, with his 1957 Topps rookie card leading the charge at a staggering $288,000. These cards not only represent the quarterback's on-field accomplishments but also serve as tangible links to a bygone era of football excellence.

For fans and collectors alike, the opportunity to own a piece of Starr's legacy is a true privilege. Whether it's the rarity, the historical significance, or the sheer allure of the quarterback's enduring impact, these cards have become highly sought-after assets that continue to captivate the sports memorabilia world.