Exploring the Top 5 Most Expensive Mickey Mantle Card Sales

By Jocelyn Alano July 03, 2024 01:38

There is nothing more appealing to a sports memorabilia collector in the hunt for iconic trading cards. The biography of the famous baseball player Mickey Mantle is encapsulated and offered through each equally legendary card, which appears on every shortlist related to sports card collecting. Here, we take a detailed look at the 5 priciest Mickey Mantle card sales including one that sold for an NFL record $12.6 million what drives up the value on any and every list like this in history's grand hobby of collectibles? Alright, fasten your seatbelts as we hit the road on a wild ride through sports cards.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by New York Yankees (@yankees)

The Legend of Mickey Mantle

The Legendary Baseball God Mickey Mantle - This player from the New York Yankees blew away the world with his talent. From the trading cards, which are now a separate category of collectibles in his own right today, each snapshot immortalized speaks to an era long past that gives context and provides contrast with where we have come from.

Top 5 Mickey Mantle Card Sales Ever Revealed

Below we look at the top 5 most expensive Mickey Mantle confirmed card sales, and delve into this exciting world of sports card collecting - touching on how a $12.6 million transaction for his Bowman rookie has rocked the entire mainstream side of detailing with an absolute shocker ripple through to territory which had previously seemed close enough but just always slightly out reach.

1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle SGC grade of 7

Valued at around $120,000 is this 1952 icon. Fast forward to August 2022 when an effectively identical card but in a PSA-graded mint condition of 9.5 sold for $12.6 million, shattering any sports piece price tag ever set on history books.

1957 Topps Mickey Mantle #95

A graded PSA 9 card from this edition went for a mind-blowing auction price in April of 2022, to the tune of $180K, and just further cemented its stature as one of THE most desirable pieces in sports memorabilia.

1958 Topps #150 Mickey Mantle

The 1958 Topps #150 Mickey Mantle card marked a pivotal point in his career and, ultimately contributed to its historical importance as well as collectible elusiveness. While sale prices for this card can vary, there is no doubt it will remain a wanted item by collectors.

1960 Topps Mickey Mantle #350

The best comp for this card is a PSA 9 that was sold in January of 2023 at auction, and it pushed $57.6K showing demand remains very high with collectors on the hunt for clean Mickey Mantle cards.

1961 Topps Mickey Mantle #300

Illustrating the strength in a field of rare and high-end Mickey Mantle cards, this PSA 9 example sold for $37,200 at an auction conducted that same month.

Unraveling the Mystery of a Mickey Mantle Baseball Card

Ultimately, with so much depth to the card market and what drives value you can see why Mickey Mantle cards are among the absolute best collectibles in that they capture ideal traits of both a future investment and an immediate high-end item.

Year of the Card

The year the card is from also greatly affects its worth. Insignificantly, the 1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle SGC7 is considered to be one of the most valuable Mickie card pieces from an estimated USD12K to a solid valuation of about US$120,000.

Condition and Grading

There are countless instances where the condition and grading of a card greatly influence its value to this extent. Cards graded by professional grading services, such as PSA or BGA garner extra value compared to their raw counterparts (gem mint 10 and mint 9 grades receive significantly higher bids).

In the End

A Mickey Mantle card has been considered rare since then. The biggest premium prices are placed on cards with limited availability, particularly those in scarce supply at the top end of card grades. That includes the 1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle, which few exemplified both the rarity and importance that this legendary artifact did in climbing to its $12.6 million record-breaking sale!
We hope you enjoyed our post and continue to explore the ever-evolving world of sports card collecting, especially when it comes to Mickey Mantle cards. Every time one of these tops changes hands, it reflects the enduring appeal and scarcity value that makes them candidates for ultimate-status sports collectibles. Growing up with the sport and newcomers alike will continue to be drawn toward Mickey Mantle cards no matter how those strains in turn affect collectors - it all amounts to a journey through one of baseball's most celebrated legacies.
With every sports card you encounter realize that each sports cards have a story — perhaps of victory and legend, or the undying heart of this beautiful game. Happy collecting!